Saturday, December 21, 2013

Trick For A Tender Turkey And Gravy


Most turkeys are not tender.  I have tried many ways to cook a turkey to try and get it tender and it has been difficult.  I have finally figured it out!  Even the breast was very tender and the trick is fairly easy.

I buy an organic turkey.  I don't want turkeys fill with antibiotics.  My turkey was about 18 pounds.  Clean out the innards and set it in a roasting pan UPSIDE DOWN.  Soften a stick of butter and brush the butter all over the turkey.

Stuff the turkey with an onion, lemon, and rosemary.  Sprinkle the turkey with salt, pepper, and thyme.  Put a meat thermometer in the deep part of the thigh.  Put it in an oven preheated to 325 degrees.

Let it cook until the thermometer reads 165 degrees.  The key is to get it out of the oven as soon as it hits this temperature.  What makes a dry turkey is overcooking it.  As soon as it reaches that temperature, take it out,  and cover with tin foil.  Let it rest for an hour or so.

Then cut off the legs and thighs.  Lay them down in the juices from the turkey and cook them for another half an hour at 325 degrees if they aren't completely done.  Take it out, carve the turkey, and enjoy!  It will be moist and delicious.

What has been your trick for a tender turkey?  If you have one, I sure would love to hear!

Turkey Gravy

Melt a stick of butter, then add 1/4 cup flour.
Add 1 teaspoon salt and 1/2 teaspoon pepper.

Pour the above ingredients into the pan that the turkey was in with all the drippings plus a cup or two of chicken or turkey broth {I used the innards of the turkey and put them in a pan with water.  Then I cooked them on low for all the hours the turkey was cooking to make turkey broth.}.  Stir until thick.

Go thy way, eat thy bread with joy, 
and drink thy wine with a merry heart;
for God now accepteth thy works.
Ecclesiastes 9:7

Comments (17)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
I agree with you that 2 smaller turkeys is better! My mom still has Christmas and Thanksgiving at her house so I don't usually cook a turkey. One year my husbands cousin covered hers in mayonnaise and Greek seasoning. It was amazing and not at all gross like I thought it would be.
1 reply · active 588 weeks ago
Sounds interesting!
Our dear family friend made the turkey this year and it was the best, most tender and moist turkey I've ever had! Everyone raved about it. She said her secret was cooking it in a bag.
Courtney's comment mentions the secret! For a no fuss, and super easy turkey brine it, put it breast down in a bag, and roast for the recommended time per pound. This means you just put it in and leave it, no basting or constantly opening the oven! Everyone constantly raves about how good my turkeys are, and can't believe it's as easy as I say. Oh and we usually do 20 to 24 pound turkeys, we have a very large family!
1 reply · active 588 weeks ago
My 'secret' is brine. I save vegetables or vegetable scraps. It's fine if they're not flawless. I start this days in advance, and if there's a cold garage or deck to use as a refrigerator, perfect. I use carrots, celery, onions, garlic and herbs like thyme, safe and rosemsty and whole peppercorns. I boil these and strain the broth. Let the vegetable broth cool and then chill. This will be used to brine my turkey.

My oven here in the Philippines is small, and necessity have taught me inventive secrets. I butcher my turkey and separate the dark meat and white meat. I save the rest of the carcass. I put the separated turkey pieces into two separate Wonderlier Tupperware bowls. I've also done the following in clean garbage bag-lined cooler. Then I add enough COLD water to my vegetable stock to fill that big pot. I add 1/3 cup salt and stir it until it dissolves completely. Them I cover the turkey pieces in the separate bowls with the brine. This brining process begins the night before I will bake the turkey.

Cover with the kids tightly and refrigerate until the next day.

Then I boil the carcass and use the broth to make my do-ahead gravy. This works perfectly because it's ready to put in a small crockpot and will be hot at dinnertime the next day.

To roast the turkey pieces, I rinse in ice cold water each piece and pat dry with paper towels. The dark meat goes in a foil-lined pan for easy clean-up, and ditto for the white meat. They fit in my small oven this way. After they're baked, I add some drippings to the gravy in the Crock Pot and it's time to eat. Perfect every time!

(typed on my phone; not proofed)

Kelley~
1 reply · active 588 weeks ago
Sounds really good! It is amazing how creative we can be when we need to be.
Danielle B's avatar

Danielle B · 588 weeks ago

I've brined it, put it in a bag and this year wrapped it in turkey. The moistest? The bacon wrapped. And Lori? The thermometer goes in the thickest part of the THIGH. The breast cooks first.
1 reply · active 488 weeks ago
No, with this method you put the thermometer in the breast since it cooks faster than the legs and thighs. This is why you cook the legs and thighs longer separately. Overcooking is what dries out the breast.
Our trick is to make a turduken. We get the butcher to de-bone a chicken, turkey, and a duck (saving the bones for stock) and then we put the smaller birds inside the turkey. The fatty duck really infuses the turkey with flavor and makes the turkey quite tender and scrumptious. It's not any harder to cook than a turkey, but make sure to find a good butcher.
1 reply · active 588 weeks ago
I like to make a lemon, parsley and garlic butter and place it between the flesh and the skin and then wrap the top in bacon which keeps in moist. It also needs to rest for quite some time - this is a very moist recipe.
http://www.goodtoknow.co.uk/recipes/510522/gordon...
1 reply · active 588 weeks ago
Cooking it upside down is the best. All of the juices flow down into the breast which normally has a tendency to dry out. Cooking it in a bag or covered roaster helps and definitely speeds up cooking time.
1 reply · active 588 weeks ago
I think I will try cooking mine upside down for Christmas. My radiologist told me his wife cooks his this way and she had to cook another one a few days after Thanksgiving since the children loved it so much!
Hi, Lori,
I have done a turkey upside down occasionally, and it does work to make the white meat more juicy. Still I find it hard to plan a meal at just the right time. If you cannot get it to the table right at the moment of reaching 165 degrees or if you need to be away for a few hours for worship or caroling, etc before a big meal, there is an alternate method. you can even leave it in overnight. We have done it twice: www.deeprootsathome.com/succulent-stress-free-tur...
Sending hugs and warm wishes to you and your family for a wonderful CHRISTmas! May your weekend and week ahead hold memories to last a lifetime as you celebrate the birth of our Savior and the promise of heaven He has given to us!
Grace, peace, and joy!
Love,
Jacqueline
I know this doesn't go along with eating healthy, but we fry ours! It's quick and it is the only way I've ever had it perfectly moist and juicy every time. My husband does it out back in his turkey fryer. But I guess you pay for that with health. Once a year though, it's heavenly!!!!

Post a new comment

Comments by