Friday, November 14, 2014

Their Divorce was NOT God's Will


The day that I heard Amy Grant was divorcing her husband was a day I'll never forget. It was in 1999. I was 41 years old with four children still in my home. I couldn't imagine divorcing my husband and destroying the lives of my children like she did. I didn't know all the details of her divorce, but I knew she was with another man shortly after.

Elspeth shared an article recently about the details concerning their divorce from Amy's ex-husband's perspective. It was written a long time ago but it still reveals some troubling things. 

"Marriage," he continues, "is like any other situation in life. If you’re trying to walk it out and honor God, you’ve got to surrender your will and lean into what you know His will is. It was not God’s will that we divorced. It wasn’t. That was not His plan. Can He take what has happened and through His miracle of grace do great things for me and for her and for everybody else involved? Yes. And He is. But that doesn’t make it right. It doesn’t. It will never make it right."

Chapman says that while his and Grant’s marriage had its share of rough waters, they had "a pretty good run" from the fall of 1986—following his admission of and subsequent recovery from drug use—until late 1994. "Our marriage has been painted as a very dark kind of thing, [that we] had trouble all along. That is not the truth. I’ve got way too many home videos and photographs and memories and laughs that bounce through my head occasionally."

But, according to Chapman, Grant came to him in late 1994 and made a declaration that took him by surprise: "I don't love you anymore. You're the biggest mistake I've ever made… I've given my heart to another man." In the November cover story, Grant told CCM MAGAZINE that she did not have an affair with Vince Gill, whom she met in 1993 at the taping of a network Christmas special. Chapman says he "chose to believe [Grant]" when she told him that the relationship with Gill was not sexual. In an interview in the Oct. 9, 1999, issue of Nashville’s daily paper, The Tennessean, Grant noted that while her relationship with Gill may have hastened the end of her marriage, she believes the final result was inevitable.

Chapman disagrees, indicating that he believes the relationship was the primary cause of the divorce. "I am torn between relying on the mathematical ability of intelligent people and the stark reality that a lot of people just don’t want to believe the obvious."

It breaks my heart to think of all the other Christian marriages that have been destroyed due to the same thinking, "I don't love you anymore." They don't understand that love is a commitment; a vow they took on their wedding day. Amy did not have one valid biblical reason to divorce her husband but somehow, this doesn't seem to matter much to some women anymore.

What therefore God hath joined together, 
let not man put asunder.
Mark 10:9

***For all of you who are divorced because you didn't "love" your husband, there is forgiveness at the cross. I don't write posts like these to judge those who have done what Amy did but to encourage any of you who are thinking of divorcing your husband for this reason to PLEASE consider changing your mind.

Comments (56)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
Loving being Mrs. W's avatar

Loving being Mrs. W · 541 weeks ago

So very, very sad! :o(
1 reply · active 247 weeks ago
Very very sad!
God hates divorce. It's as simple as that. God also sees the fall out from a divorce. Lives are shattered - it's like throwing a glass on a ceramic floor - broken pieces everywhere. There are too few people who mentor others to stay there and trust God to work in the marriage. It's like 2 pieces of paper glued together; you take the papers apart and you have ruined paper. Those who are forgiven by God; forgive others and they do not keep an account of the wrongs.
1 reply · active 249 weeks ago
I am one of those people that is referred to in this blog. It has been 9 years ago that I left my husband. It took a few years after leaving, and a few years into my marriage of today, that I began to understand I had done something very wrong.
I do have my story that may be different in many ways from others, but it still boils down to having my focus on the wrong thing and deciding the grass would be greener on the other side. There were many wrong steps that lead to my divorce. In other words it didn't happen overnight.
I will admit there are definitely things about my current marriage that I truly am grateful for that my first did not have. I will never say though that it was right or that I had good cause to divorce my first. No matter all of the details of what that marriage was like, from day one to year 28, I was WRONG.
Only through Loris blog have I come to realize how I could have made a difference in my first marriage. I am very thankful for my belief that I have been forgiven but I think the healing may continue until I die.
There is so much more I could share, but will leave it at that. I am also very thankful for Lori's blog that helps me strife to be the wife I should be now. It truly does make a difference.
Thank you for the courage to share the truth Lori and Ken. Continued blessings always.
1 reply · active 151 weeks ago
I read this and I understand that you don't divorce because you just decide one day that you don't love them anymore. However right now in my life I have only been married almost 6 years and through this whole time my husband has drank his life away and become someone I do not know- not coming home at night, throwing things when angry, saying things that are so hurtful yet he refuses to acknowledge them- the list goes on. I am sure he has committed adultery but I cannot prove it. My heart tried for so long- forgiving and giving chances over and over. My heart can not do it anymore. I have been gone now for a month and I wonder how can God use me after I now have left and am filing for divorce.... I prayed to God through my whole marriage trying so hard. I know I have been saved by grace and shown so much mercy. I just never knew my heart could become so cold towards a human being- my husband who I chose to love every day we were married. Now I read things like this and I read that verse and all I do is beg God to not make me go back, go back to where I was dying every day inside and literally. I always question myself how could I have done better? What did I do wrong- I have done every bible study out there...I really tried. I can barely type as tears come down....but at this point I would rather be single and alone for the rest of my life than be with the man I married.... I truly wants God to be pleased with me, that one day He will say well done my faithful servant....I just don;t know if that is possible anymore
6 replies · active 230 weeks ago
Lady Virtue's avatar

Lady Virtue · 541 weeks ago

I well remember Amy Grant's divorce from Gary Chapman also. Some 15 years on, I still find it very, very sad. I do not listen to the genre of music known as CCM, of which they are a part, but it really has a negative effect on the testimony of a professing Christian when she abandons her husband. Christians, of all people, are to be covenant keepers and to follow through in doing what we've said we would. So many men are fearful of marrying today because of this very thing.

Society encourages women: "You go girl!" "You don't need no man!" Even if you have children, "kick him to the curb and raise them alone." "Show everyone what a strong, independent woman you are." It's absolutely heartbreaking. Lord, strengthen women of God to live as salt and light in this dark, wicked world. I hate feminism.
1 reply · active 306 weeks ago
Wow! We have several of her cd's in our collection. And I knew she had divorced. But I guess I fell for her side of the story. I had never really read his side but I ony knew he had a drug problem and I thought wow! What a jerk!
I'll pass this on to my husband and see if he agrees to get rid of her music. He always said there was something about her he didn't feel comfortable with.
1 reply · active 335 weeks ago
If she cheated with Gill, then he has biblical reason to divorce her.
3 replies · active 315 weeks ago
I was heart broken over that divorce! I never wanted to hear her music or watch her in anything after that! I was glad to read the other side of the story! Marriage is not easy, even when you marry a great guy! We are all sinners! Separation for safety is a must, but divorce is a different kind of trouble that will always stay with you! God hates it!
3 replies · active 364 weeks ago
In this society, the lie that we are supposed to believe is that we only have one life to live, and life is too short to spend it with Mr. Wrong. We think our own personal happiness is paramount, to be pursued at any cost, and it is better to be divorced than unhappily married. It is also a lie that how happily married we are depends on whether we found Mr. Right, our "soulmate". Up until 6 months ago, this is how I thought. Then God intervened and brought me through my senses, in part through blogs like the Peaceful Wife, the Peaceful Wife Phillipines, and Lori's blog. I now know that the truth is that as Christians, it is NOT about us and our happiness. We surrendered that at the cross and are living sacrifices to God, his workmanship, created to do good works. How happy we are in our marriage depends on us fixing our eyes on God and doing our part as wives, NOT on whether we are married to Mr. Right. And we need to stop watching movies like the Notebook.
1 reply · active 541 weeks ago
Loving being Mrs. W's avatar

Loving being Mrs. W · 541 weeks ago

I find it so very sad that people fall out of love. (for a better way of saying it) It really makes me so sad that we live in a through away society and that it now includes marriage! I am so grateful to God and my precious Hubby that we have fallen more and more in love as the years have gone on, not because we are a perfect couple but because we know a perfect God and He is always there to help us stay in His Word and to love each other as His Word tells us too.
It's not hard to have a warm and loving marriage all it takes is putting your spouse first and not yourself; for that is what Jesus did for us!
Antony often tells me that he can’t believe that I love him so very much and that it blesses him no end. I always reply with the fact that I can’t believe at times that he loves me so very much. We have both come to the conclusion that love in marriage is a gift and miracle from God and we don’t need to have to understand it we just need to enjoy it with a grateful heart. True Godly love NEVER gives up on the other person and that includes our spouse! In fact I do believe our spouse should be at the top of the list!!!
Love to all.
1 reply · active 541 weeks ago
Loving being Mrs. W's avatar

Loving being Mrs. W · 541 weeks ago

That should of been throw away! Note to self it may be a good idea not to type something while half knocked out on pain killers!
Sorry Lori. oxo
Marriage is a microcosm of the relationship between a believer and Christ. In marriage we learn of commitment, self sacrifice, love, and more. The man loving and protecting the woman teaches us how Christ loves and protects us, the woman respecting and serving her husband teaches us to serve and respect Christ. Once we understand this, the concept of divorce is so much more deplorable.

I've had plenty of women come to me with stories of what their husband has done or failed to do, looking for my support, hoping I will validate the choice they want to make by telling them, "Yes, he has done enough. God would want you to go." Instead, I ask a question, "Are you done being forgiven by Christ?" Maybe you have forgiven and forgiven, and you feel like your words fall on deaf ears. Maybe you are tired of having the same conversation over and over with seemingly no end in sight. Maybe you aren't happy about the person he is at this moment. So what? Couldn't our heavenly brother say the same of us? What if He was tired of forgiving us because He had done it so many times before, far more times than *we* have ever forgiven anyone? What if He was tired of His words falling on deaf ears, which they do, and decided to cut His losses? Do any of us think that He is totally happy with who we are at this moment? He asks for perfection, and tells us to strive to perfect ourselves, with His help and power, so unless we are perfect than we are not yet what He wants us to be. Forgive as you want to be forgiven. If you are done being forgiven by Christ, then by all means be done forgiving others. If not, then it is time to buck up and learn about patience and self sacrifice.
1 reply · active 541 weeks ago
My wife is a strong Christian. She believes the scriptures. As far as I know, there is no other lover causing her to want to be rid of me. I really don't know how to rationalize what is going on: How can such a wife (like so many other "good" church women) file for divorce, when that is so clearly not approved by the Lord? She refuses me all affection and accountability, which is also clearly not obeying God's word. Now she has talked herself into the idea that every fault of mine ought to be spotlighted, and nothing of the good in our 40-year relationship is remembered. That women cruelly ditch their husbands like this is not so surprising. What IS surprising is that strong Christian women like Amy Grant so commonly can conscience it. Then too, where is the church?... and where are biblical counselors? I'll tell you: Instead of guiding a sister who has gone off the path, they are enabling or outright supporting such women. If all Christians refused to buy Amy Grant's music and they denounced what she did, and if any Christian music venues refused her, and the local church would not allow her to participate (like 1cor5 says) would this kind of thing be so common? But really I do not want to explain and complain about why marriages fail, I want to know how to fix mine! Seeing that rebellious wives are so common, has no one found the answer?
2 replies · active 540 weeks ago
Barry Chandler's avatar

Barry Chandler · 451 weeks ago

This reminds me of my experience. I was an ordained minister for 21 yrs in the AG and married for that same length of time. My now ex-wife and I met in Bible college and married shortly after I took a position at a church where we both serve the Lord together. Though we had our challenged and struggles I never once questioned her devotion to God and our marriage. Yes there were times we had verbal arguments and there were times I said some things that were wrong and hurtful, but what marriage hasn't had moments like this? Our ministry was one of extreme difficulty to the urban core and this brought tremendous pressure even on our marriage, but we always seem to be able to talk through our problems and practice forgiveness. In the fall of 2013 I discovered she had a secret affair going on for nearly a year with an illegal Mexican in our church with 3 small children. Upon confronting her about this, she admitted it was true and then came the words "I haven't loved you for a long time." She tried to say it had nothing to do with this man, but I knew better. I offered forgiveness but her heart was too bound up in this relationship to let it go. One month later she left our family of 3 teenage kids and moved out telling our kids it was because she didn't love me anymore but not telling them about her boyfriend. This woman I loved and pledged vows with walked out of our marriage with no biblical reason for doing so. Soon my kids found out about her boyfriend but somehow mom was given a free pass. What is even more shocking it see how many of her Christian friends have supported her in this rebellion and not taken the biblical approach in addressing this sin. Now our family and church has been destroyed in this decision. Yes it is sad to see this being played out in so many "Christian" marriages when we are suppose to be examples and Christ like.
While going through this article and some posted comments and replies, I feel like making some inputs. First of all, I will like to link my article on Nigeria world, which I wrote for a man of God who was going through marital challeges, whose wife was divorcing. Because of the way he was handling the situation, or his statements in front of millions of viewers on His TV program, I was moved to write this appeal to him. Here is the link:
http://nigeriaworld.com/feature/publication/glori...

I had too many marital challenges, and eventually, I decided to write this book to help couples understand divine principles and purposes of marriage; the foundation of marriage and God's purpose for marriage.
Many people enter into marriage because they think they are matured, and the Body of Christ in general have not been thoroughly spending enough time and resources to educate the people of God concerning God's purpose for marriage. Praise God for those who do. God has laid down principles for marriage, which except we follow such principles, we make a shipwreck of our homes which are supposed to be a safety place for our children. In my book, I touched my marital experiences, and how I almost lost my life and those of my four children in the marriage. God miraculously rescued us when I took the right steps.

One thing is sure: Do not marry an unbeliever, or someone whose salvation is not sure. Just as the LORD commanded His people, the people of Israel not to intermarry with the heathen so that they don't contaminate them, in the same way He warns us not to marry unbelievers for according to the word of God: what partnership has the Temple of God with Baal; or light and darkness? 2 Corinthians 6:14-16.

Finally, it is only the house that is built upon the Rock that shall survive storms and rough winds of life (Mathew 7:24-28). It is only when we build our marriages on the foundation the LORD laid it that we have successful marriage . This is the link to my books:
https://www.amazon.com/s/ref=nb_sb_noss?url=searc...
It's titled:

Revisiting the foundation of marriage: Embracing Divine Principles for a successful Marriage.
A christian divorce is heartbreaking, reading some of these comments, there are some very strong christian women and men promoting this Holy Union which i think is God's desire. Standing before Almighty God making marriage vows is to be take very very seriously. I do understand separation is needed in many cases and I believe prayer is required not only by those involved, but many christians praying together for the healing of the marriage. Divorce is not God's way. A complete surrender to The Lord is required and confession of all sin and a desire to be Christ like is paramount. The enemy is in the business of destroying christian marriages and the battle is spiritual , something that is not taken seriously by many christians. My precious christian wife divorced me five years ago, the reason she says is she believes it was not God's will we married. The fact is my nephew murdered his girlfriend and my wife couldn't handle being part of this family. Also a few years prior..two foul words slipped past my lips..something i went and prayed abut with my pastor and it never happened again. A spirit of bitterness and unforgiveness i believe has prevented forgiveness on her part..she admitted she has never got over it .l pray everyday for restoration even now and still wear my wedding ring. There are still two of us in this marriage, myself and The Lord. Unfortunately my wife sought counselling by what i can only describe as worldly people. Not one person prayed for the marriage with her. I still love her today and am faithful and i know she has not seen anybody. Please if you will, pray for restoration of what the locusts have eaten for myself, Paul and Kimberlyn..how great it would be if she had friends like some of you who have commented in favour of biblical marriage..God bless you all in Jesus' name..Paul
3 replies · active 361 weeks ago
I was about 22 when I heard about Amy's divorce. I was greatly saddened as when I got saved as a teen, her music was the first christian music I heard, and i had all of her albums. I lived in Nashville at the time. I knew her home address because of my husbands work, so I wrote her and told her how wrong I felt it was. I told her that it was disappointing. I shared with her that I had gossiped about her, not knowing the full story, and had apologized for that. She mailed me a hand written card that said 'thank God we all have the freedom to grow and change'. at the time, I was young and didnt understand alot of things.
It is no about 28 years later. I was married to a pastor and we had many children together. When we hit the 26 yr mark, he decided he no longer loved me, but also he didnt care about God anymore. It was a horrible time for me as we had a great marriage up to that point. There was little indication of unhappiness. He did begin to get depressed adn withdrawn, when i asked what was wrong he just said 'oh periodically i lose passion in areas, but like always i will get over it'. He went on a mission trip, that i later discovered was really a 'meet his mistress' trip that he had been corresponding with via phone and internet. I forgave him when i found out...I tried to stay, but he continued to make it clear he couldnt help it that he didnt love me. He said i was a great wife, he had no complaints that he just didnt love me. He ended that relationship with me standing by the phone. He said he would work on our marriage, but he remained distant, cold and mechanical. Then when our congregation found out, he began to get hostile, curse me, and the blaming began. I stayed a year, but within that time he began another relationship. I decided I was not going to stay while he played the field. I just could not handle that. He signed a confession to adultery and our divorce went through in 4 months. God did bring a godly man in my life, rather quickly, and i think that was God's grace and mercy as I had many children to care for. When I look back I have peace that I clung to God through it all, I had a godly elderly lady walk me through every week that year, several times a year. She helped me alot. My church was supportive. You arent told how to walk through something like this, ....I know I didnt do all things right, I was hurting so much and did not have a husband who was repentant and trying to restore , but when I meet women going through it I do council them to stay. I can know give more practical advice because even if you are grounded it is hard to know how to walk this path. There are only a few things I would have been able to do differently....but I would try it for the sake of my kids. They have suffered just as much and in some ways more than I in this trial. Because of my ex's choices several of his children do not like him, and one wont even speak to him. I love him as a lost person and pray for him. I dont think any divorce is Gods will and it is not something i wanted, and I know i will never understand why. I have learned to leave that with God. But how a 'godly' man can be so wonderful, preach so well, turn so quickly and so hard, i have no idea. to this day he rarely goes to church., he now drinks and parties, and is married to one of the women he met while 'working on our marriage'.
1 reply · active 315 weeks ago
Reading about Amy's divorce makes me so sad for so many people. It could most likely been avoided if she never had allowed herself to be close to another man. She should have protected her marriage. She had an affair of the heart even if it wasn't sexual. For all women reading this, read Laura Doyle's books The Surrendered Wife and The Empowered Wife. They should change your views on things in your marriage. Beware they are not from a Christian perspective and should be read understanding this.
What goes around comes around. I understand Vince and Amy's marriage isn't a bed of roses anymore.
The saddest part of this story is the sadness of both sets of children. Amy's children loved their daddy very much and Vince's wife and daughter loved him very much. If Amy wanted to leave her husband, the father of her children. she should have never taken another woman's husband.
All I can say is, thank God for His forgiveness, grace, and mercy.
just read this I too was sad when she divorced for Vince gill always thought it seemed so unbiblical from such a "biblical" person...never could understand that....now I do so thank you.
Well, here is something else to think about: there are some wolves in sheep's clothing.

I, too, was stunned by Amy's divorce. But listen, dear sisters and brothers: I was married to a "Christian" man also, for 15 years. Wow, did he ever fool everyone. Elder in the church, leader of men's ministry... A more charming man you have never met. When I read Gary Chapman's words, I think my ex could have said the very same thing.

What people who haven't experienced a narcissist don't ever understand is this: narcissists LIE, they misrepresent, and they are always "the victim." My narc left me with 3 children, and then left the country to work for a worldwide Christian ministry! He traveled the world, preaching the gospel! As soon as he left us, he had a serious girlfriend, which confirms my suspicions that he was never faithful to our marriage. Now that he's retired from Christian ministry, he is openly living with that woman (to whom he is STILL not married, some 10 years later!).

Something else I'd like to point out is this: Amy hasn't said anything bad about Gary. She has alluded to the marriage being rocky, but nothing specific. Why? Because she loves her children. She has allowed her children to continue to love their dad, and to come to their own conclusions in adulthood. Decent parents don't malign the ex to their children. Yet Gary has had no problem maligning Amy.

My point is this: not a one of us knows the whole story. We live in a fallen world, and we are all sinners. When I read some of these posts about "rebellious wives," Oh. My. Goodness! Yikes! And they can't figure out why their wives fled?
George Dragan's avatar

George Dragan · 338 weeks ago

I appreciate this story. Part of me always wanted to give Amy Grant the benefit of the doubt, but if she truly said, "I don't love you anymore," then there is no benefit to give. Sometimes true love requires separation when there is serious and constant (and I mean serious) abuse in a relationship and the guilty party refuses help, but there is no excuse for relying on the fleeting feelings of love as the bellweather for committed agape which is a decision. Grant should have known that as she sang about it in some of her early songs of the mid 80's (Straight Ahead--her best album in my view). So, allowing herself to "fall in love with" another man when she should have been committed in marriage to her spouse shows a major lack of personal depth and understanding of the realities and theology of marriage. For a great read on the subject, read Love and Responsibility by Karol Wojtyla.

Post a new comment

Comments by