Tuesday, February 2, 2016

Wimpy, Cowardly Parenting



Do you ask your children to do something or do you tell them? When you ask them, you are giving them a choice as to whether or not they want to obey you. If you tell them what to do and have trained them to obey you immediately, they will do what you have asked. Today's parents ask their children to do things; "Will you pick up your toys?" "No," answers the child, "I don't feel like it right now" or "I'm too busy playing video games to do this." Too many of today's parents have no clue how to raise their children and it is because they have gone so far from God's Word in this area.

Leonard Sax has written a great book about this topic. This is the generation of self-esteem and entitlements. Parents are no longer parents but are afraid of their children. They think if they're strict with their children, their children will grow up to not like them. However, studies have proven that children grow up loving the parents who are stricter with them than more lenient because they learn to be disciplined adults. “Most American parents are completely confused and going utterly in the wrong direction,” Sax said. “There’s a collapse of understanding what parenting involves.” The hierarchy of parent over child no longer exists, he said. Instead of parents exercising their authority because they know what’s best, they are focusing on making children happy and boosting their self-esteem.

Dr. Sax goes through a list of things to help raise better children: have family meals, take screens out of the bedrooms, limit screens usage, teach humility, and be a parent to your children. These are all great things and I recommend them for all parents with their children. Sax cites numerous research studies that found that a lack of parental authority is why obesity is on the rise, why more kids are on anti-anxiety and attention deficit disorder medication, why children are a culture of disrespect, seem fragile, and why American children no longer lead the world in education.

Michael Pearl has a different viewGod's Word commands parents to use the rod for a reason. "The rod can bring repentance, but it goes much deeper than that. The rod in the hands of a discerning parent who will supply the child’s soul with that moment of judgment that he feels he so deserves. Properly applied, with instruction, it will absolve the child of guilt, cleanse his soul, and give him a fresh start through a confidence that all indebtedness is paid.” You shall strike him with the rod and rescue his soul from Sheol {Proverbs 23:14}. {Contrary to popular opinion, the Pearls do NOT teach child abuse! Read their book for yourself and you will see that they do not. He recommends calling the authorities if there is any physical abuse. Part of loving a child is disciplining them the way the Lord has commanded we discipline them.}

I was at the park the other day with my grandchildren. There was a young dad there with his two year old daughter. We got to talking about discipline and I asked him if he spanked his daughter and he responded, 
"No, but there are sure times when I wish I could. My wife's best friend has her masters in child psychology and told us of all the harm spanking does to children. We have friends that have five and seven year old daughters that are the sweetest children I've ever been around. I asked them what they did to teach their daughters to be so sweet and they told me they spanked them." 

Then he showed me these bloody scratches on his hands from his daughter scratching him. He has no idea how to make her stop. I asked him if he was spanked as a child and he said he was. I went over to him and told him, "You know you are the man of the family. You should be able to spank your daughter if you feel this is what she needs." I could tell he was very agitated by my words because he knew I was right and his wife's friend was wrong. He told me spanking was so fast and effective and all of his friends where spanked when they were young. I can tell you right now our children would have never gotten away with giving us bloody scratches on our hands. Modern psychology teaches wimpy, cowardly parenting and children are suffering as a result.

All children will chose to sin. They know they have sinned and should be punished. Yet, many parents are at a loss as to what they should do with a child who has disobeyed them. They believe that all they have to do is love the child and try coaxing them towards obedience. We can do all those things this doctor has suggested but it still may not produce disciplined children. Children need to be disciplined. A couple swats on the fanny teach children obedience quickly. Nothing works better than this.

He who withholds his rod hates his son,
 But he who loves him disciplines him diligently.
Proverbs 23:24

Comments (41)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
I agree that parents should be the authority over their children and the children should obey them. However, I simply don't agree that spanking in necessary to raise children. Sure, it may be "easier" for a parent to spank them to get obedience from them but parents should not raise children is a way that it is easiest for them but should raise them the best way. In my family, we do not spank our children nor was my parents spanked. So this is timeline goes back to the 1940's with raising children properly without spanking and yet there is not one person out of all the family how have followed the wrong path, gotten divorce etc.
I agree that parent should not be scratched etc by their children but there is a very wide path between being passive with their children and letting them rule the roost and spanking them. Raising children is about choosing the best method and not the easiest method.
2 replies · active 477 weeks ago
Lack of parental authority definitely is running rampant in our society. I myself am guilty of putting a question mark at the end of a statement---and often don't know why I am doing it! Then I correct myself and put a period at the end. :) (of course, my 5 year old says, "ummm, no" when I ASK him to do something!) I think we young parents today were raised so haphazardly by the culture that there was no one around training us and giving us orders to show us how to live rightly. We kids of the 80s (in my experience) were mostly raised by public schools, TV, and friends. What's authority? Question authority!! we were taught...

I love that you told the man to "know his role"! :) It probably was exactly what he'd been waiting to hear!!

I am not trying to nit pick or criticize, but want to add this for your readers' sake:
Please know there are exceptions, such as children with special needs, in whom spanking has no affect but rather gives them confusion and a feeling of insecurity as they do not process events the same as neurotypical children. It can be very damaging and scarring to spank a special needs child because they view it as an attack and it does not have the same desired effect as it does on others. I followed the biblical advice of another blogger whom I highly respected, and her advice was spot-on for average children, but I applied it to my autistic son (who I did not realize was autistic till later) and it has given him a lot of issues. Just sharing my experience. Thanks! God bless!
4 replies · active 477 weeks ago
I spank my kids, but very rarely. And I would only ever use my hand and through their clothing. My mom spanked us with my dad's belt and pants pulled down...I feel that was very wrong. I honestly find other forms of discipline more effective (going to bed early, extra chores, loss of privileges, etc.) More effective. I am strict and have well behaved children, and honestly don't find spanking necessary very often.
1 reply · active 477 weeks ago
I believe that consistency can be as effective as spanking, or more effective when spanking is done wrong. But there are times when a good swat on the bottom gets the child's respect faster and easier than time outs and early to bed.

Many non-spanking parents are yellers or demeaning in their language towards their child, especially as they get older. This is far worse than a swat or two on the behind.

Generally most spanking should be done by the time a child turns 6. If a parent has been consistent the child will have learned life long respect for a parent and self-discipline. There are few if any greater gifts that a parent can give to their children than to teach them discipline. The same discipline they will ultimately receive from the State and from the consequences of their own sins if they are not properly trained as children. I have heard far too many lament that they wish their parents had been more consistent, harder on them, and given them some good old fashioned consequences with spanking to have helped them on their journey of self-discipline. Without discipline in our lives the flesh often rules and so many dreams of a successful life get harmed, all because a parent was unwilling to apply discipline to the child.
1 reply · active 477 weeks ago
Lori

We were spanked as children and it was quick and effective!, some punishments can be long and drawn out and the child doesn't even remember what they did in the first place but spanking is immediate and works well. If the bible says it, we should be doing it and not considering it out of date or 'wrong'. The word of God is pure and perfect and endures forever.
blessings
Helen UK
1 reply · active 477 weeks ago
Amen! Love To Train Up a Child! The book does nor say that spanking should be used as the training tool either! But it is a necessary tool that God COMMANDS us to use.
3 replies · active 477 weeks ago
Let me start by saying i am not against spanking, however I would not endorse the methods of Michael Pearl. He advocates swatting infants as young as six months. There is no need for that. James Dobson is more my speed. I will not support someone who often speaks of children like they are animals. "Conditioning" an infant through blanket training is not "teaching". A baby under a year old is supposed to explore. It is how they learn. Please stop endorsing this man.
11 replies · active 477 weeks ago
Michelle, I have watched as my 6 month old pitched a massive fit. One quick sharp smack to the top of the leg put a quick stop to it. But once they have calmed down they got lots of cuddles and kisses. And it never left a mark and was never done in anger.

All of my 8 children are fine. And very affectionate. As for special needs children, I have grown up with siblings with autism and I have a special needs child myself. My mother used to give excuses when my sister would have angry outbursts or do something else wrong. ' oh, it's not her fault, it's the autism.' But we all knew she knew exactly what she was doing wrong and was quite pleased she was getting away with it.

My daughter also responds to smacking. Most people think she doesn't understand but she does! You really have to gauge their level of understanding, and their response. We have a friend who has a child with Down's syndrome. She loves to throw glassware and run away from her parents, despite the danger. You can tell by the smile on her face she knows exactly what she is doing. But her parents won't smack her for it. Every special needs child is different. Some respond to spankings, some don't. Some would respond to it, but their parents are doing it wrong, they get a bad response and so they give up.
5 replies · active 477 weeks ago
I'm amazed by how instantly God's instruction (spanking/rod) works. When I am regularly training, instructing and administering spankings, my children are a joy to be around. I spank my children because 1. it is commanded by God and 2. It allows me to enjoy my kids
I am in no way an expert parent but I'm thankful for God's wisdom in child training and I have been greatly blessed by the Pearls ministry concerning training.
Spanking is not the easy way to parent but it is the Godly way. And His ways are higher and better than mine.
1 reply · active 477 weeks ago
I agree that discipline is extremely important for children. I have 4 - aged 12, 11, 9 and 3. They are all obedient, and Mr 3 is getting there. But here in NZ (and some other countries too, I believe) it is actually illegal to spank children. Police do have the power to choose not to prosecute if the spanking was very minor, but there is still an investigation and a lot of stress put on the family.
1 reply · active 477 weeks ago
I love the Pearl's to Train Up a Child book. When I hear people bashing it I silently shake my head, and wish they could experience what our family has experienced.

We weren't against spanking. In fact we used to think that it is the preferred method to train and discipline your child. After reading the book it wasn't the spanking or swatting that grabbed our attention, but the training and building of a relationship. We started doing everything together. Whatever I was working they did what ever they could to help. We sang, worked, played. ....... together. We read together, had long conversations ...... when something came up that needed attention it was dealt with immediately. By investing time in our children we have a completely different atmosphere in our home. One of joy, respect, ....... It was only a few months ago my husband and I were talking about parenting and realized we have not spanked or hit our children in over six years. (Our youngest is four) It has not been necessary. We have very well behaved, thoughtful, caring children. Thanks to the Pearls.

Post a new comment

Comments by