Wednesday, October 29, 2014

Is Teaching a Good Career for Mothers?


Society tells us that being a teacher is a good career for a mother. She is only working when the children are in school and home when the children are at home. Did anyone ever think of asking the children what they thought about this?

On my post She Was Always There, several women commented that their mothers were teachers, very good teachers but they felt robbed because of it. Some said their mothers gave all they had to the children they taught and had nothing left for them when their mothers got home. Another one said that her mother never taught her the fine arts of keeping a home.

I substituted for awhile when my youngest was in junior high. I noticed that all the female teachers were dragging by the end of the day. I was exhausted when I came home and could hardly move. I would lay on the couch and stay there a long time. My poor daughter, who I was suppose to be home schooling, was not getting much of my time or attention. I also taught full-time the first two years of my oldest daughter's life. I felt like I wasn't a good wife, mother or teacher because I was so overwhelmed.

Teaching is exhausting. It takes a ton of energy to teach a bunch of children. One of my friends who had children and was a teacher said it was like running a marathon. I have never wanted to run a marathon so it sure did not appeal to me.

One of the teachers at this fine Christian school told me that she could always tell the students who had SAHMs verses moms who worked outside of the home. She told me the students who had full-time mothers at home were more secure and happy.

Saying all this, I love teachers and am very thankful for them but I will always encourage mothers who have children at home to be home full-time with their children, if at all possible. Single women, women with no children or children who are all grown up have a lot more time and energy needed to invest in teaching and they don't have children at home that need them.

Something always suffers when we extend ourselves beyond what we should. It is usually the marriage that suffers, unfortunately. We fail to realize that the best thing we can do for our children is to stay married to their father until death do us part. Our marriage should always be a top priority in our lives.

I will therefore that the younger women marry, 
bear children, guide the house, give none occasion 
to the adversary to speak reproachfully.
I Timothy 5:14
photo source

Comments (48)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
You are so right about teachers giving everything to their students and have nothing to give to their own family when they come home. I am NOT a teacher, but a church secretary who only works when my son is in school...I also have NOTHING left in me to give to my family at the end of the day. I hate it and am being so convicted about it. Your post came at the perfect time for me to read. I am so tired of rushing around like a crazy person to get it all done. I am starting to be resentful of my husband for not helping me around the house. You see, I was once a SAHM who thought that when her last child went to school, people wouldn't understand if I still stayed home and didn't work...so, I went to work. At a church no less...surely God would approve?! I have been miserable ever since.
3 replies · active 543 weeks ago
Anne Kantz's avatar

Anne Kantz · 543 weeks ago

Lori,
Reading your blog was one of the ways I was convicted to give up my full time teaching job to stay home with my two children. I worked during my son's first years and then went back shortly after my second child and I ALWAYS felt like I couldn't give 100% to either place, home or school. I wanted to be perfect at both, but I was always so stressed and worn out. Thank you Lori for your wise words!
1 reply · active 543 weeks ago
This is so true. Also, a teacher takes her work home with her. There are lessons to plan and papers to grade. She often spends her evenings and weekends working on that, along with being tired, mentally and physically. And to make matters worse, I doubt that she is getting a proper amount of rest to be her best for her family.
2 replies · active 543 weeks ago
Excellent post! I completely agree! During our first year of marriage, I taught 50% of the time. On my working days, I would come home exhausted and lay on the couch for most of the night. My days off were spent frantically trying to catch up on cleaning, cooking, lesson planning, etc. I was stressed out and had nothing left for my husband. Now I am a substitute teacher, so there is no planning and I can work as much (or little) as I feel up to. We have no children, but I cannot imagine working outside the home (full or part-time), especially as a teacher with my own family and home to take care of!
1 reply · active 543 weeks ago
Lady Virtue's avatar

Lady Virtue · 543 weeks ago

My mom was a teacher when my brother and I were growing up. She says she knew from childhood that that was what she wanted to do. But I have heard her express regret about it more recently. She struggled with juggling lesson plans, grading papers, creating arts and crafts to decorate her classroom, cooking and cleaning at home, helping my brother and me with homework, etc. Whew! I can't imagine was it was like to live that out.

For someone who grew up in the '80s, God graciously spared our home from a lot of things growing more common back then, like divorce. My dad had the same employer for 30 plus years and was the family breadwinner. But, looking back on it, I do wish my mom had been a bit more available.
2 replies · active 543 weeks ago
I think teaching can be a good career for someone who is not married yet. IF you can get your teaching certificate without going into debt. I learned a lot about child development, time management, and other useful skills while teaching. It can also lead to a side income of tutoring when you get married and have kids....
1 reply · active 543 weeks ago
I think many women have chosen teaching as a career because we are to teach our children from the time they are born until we die. God instilled it in us. Unfortunately society convinced women to do their teaching outside the home. When mothers work outside the home, they can't teach all they need to teach their children to know so they can continue the cycle to stay home as mothers themselves one day. If you feel inadequate at homemaking, you may find the workplace easier and more rewarding ($, self satisfying). I have had to train myself to really "work" in the home since I lacked the training growing up. I agree with the statements that mothers lack energy for their families after working all day (I worked 14 yrs, 2nd shift, having four children and home schooling before God said enough, and I gave in, decided to trust Him to take care of us just like He promises and let my husband do the providing and quit). I have a friend whose mother was a teacher and raised animals, canned her garden food, raised three children, but never taught her children how to keep a home or any of the things she did. So sad that all her knowledge and efforts in life went to others over her own children. Same thing with my MIL, who was a teacher too. My SIL can't cook, iron, sew on a button, etc, because even though her mother did all of those things, she never taught them to her daughter. I have taught my girls using the Keepers at Home club. It has several skills (aside from cleaning and cooking) for girls to learn to be competent SAHM . I also lead a group (this is similar to girl scouts, but emphasizes being home and not leaders of the community) and many mothers (also SAHM) have asked to learn skills as well. It's wonderful that so many women here recognize the importance of mothers being home.
1 reply · active 543 weeks ago
So I've been thinking about this. You always have these "I can do it all and I don't know why everyone else has a hard time with it" types who comment on your blog. They swear they have no trouble working full time, cooking delicious meals, helping the kids with homework, folding clothes during down times etc... So maybe some people really are built this way. These women can be full time teachers. Everyone else should consider putting their career on hold, or switch to part time like a job-share arrangement. Either that or if their mom is willing to be a full-time grandma and help out with the kids everyday, then that could work too. That's how Asian families do it. Grandma and grandpa live in the same house and the adults both work full time. The grandparents help with homework and do all of the cooking.
1 reply · active 543 weeks ago
As a teacher (not working currently, but licensed), I don't know about all this. Yes, some women are dragging by the end of the day. But you're going to find that no matter the profession--even as a SAHM. I know when I was a SAHM that wasn't working, I HATED it. I loved my kids, but it just wasn't for me. Now I'm a WAHM and it is SO much better for me and my family. Just because some people don't have enough energy for both does not mean that moms who work neglect their children. The right work (or no work) is wherever God calls you.
4 replies · active 543 weeks ago
Hi Lori, I completely agree with you. I don't know if you remember me I am currently working full time from home in Australia to help my husband pay off our home. We have had some fertility issues which have meant we have not had children yet.
I truly believe in Gods timing, I found out a month ago I was going to be made redundant early next year, with the final payout it will pay off our home ( almost to the dollar!) and last week we found out we are expecting in June next year!
We are beyond thrilled that the Lord has blessed us so much. I look forward to starting my new chapter as stay at home wife and mother. Thanks to your blog I can see the importance of that role!
Hoping you are well

Miriam
1 reply · active 543 weeks ago
I think so many women choose to work because they feel that they just aren't contributing as much as their husbands to the family. Even if that were the case (which I really don't believe--raising children is just as important as providing their home!) staying at home with the children is such a favor to your husband! It's much easier to focus at work and provide well when you know that if a child gets sick, your wife is there to pick the child up from school, nurse them back to health. If your husband has to go out of town for work, how much easier must that work trip be when he knows that he doesn't have to find child-care and they are being taken care of by his wife? It, of course, is good for the children and is your calling by the Lord. But it's also such a wonderful blessing to your husband that he can work and not have to worry about his children too!
4 replies · active 543 weeks ago
My mother was a school teacher at a small country primary school. I attended the same school whilst in Primary school, therefore travelled to and from school with her. After reading the comments I feel completely blessed as my mother wasn’t a worn out mess by the end of the day – perhaps teaching in the country (in Australia) is less demanding or perhaps after years of teaching my mother had it down pat and teaching was no longer as difficult as it is for new teachers. She returned to teaching in 1971 when my brothers were at school and when I started school. Some of my friends had SAHMs, others had mums that worked on their farms etc.. we all accepted what our parents did and we all knew they were working hard. It was just the way of life in the country. None of us had regrets or wished for anything different.

With my three older brothers - once at home, we all were expected to helped with the chores and make dinner. Dad was home all the time as he was a farmer and I have to say I had a wonderful childhood. Mum taught me all my homemaking skills, in particular how to cook and run a home but also lots of different crafts and sewing. She was very keen on increasing my knowledge in the arts and encouraged me with music, art and literature. She took all four of us to music lessons each week, I was hopeless at piano!!!. I don't want to make it sound too good, but it was really was a wonderful childhood.
3 replies · active 543 weeks ago
Thank you so much for your blog ( I know, I have said this before), but I am always so encouraged by it. Sometimes I feel so archaic, with my contentedness to stay at home, home school my children, and to enjoy my family. I sometimes wonder if there is something wrong with me, that I don't have any career aspirations or great desire to travel and experience everything. Thank you for encouraging me to work hard at home. It is so nice to hear a voice, that often isn' t heard . God bless.
3 replies · active 543 weeks ago
This may sound harsh, but every time I hear a mother say 'I tried being a SAHM and it just didn't work for ME'. Leaves me shaking my head. They answered their own question in that one statement. 'It didn't work for MEEEEE!!!!!' That's just it. If God has created and commanded women to be keepers at home, then pure joy should be found in that role. If it 'didn't work' for you then usually the problem is 1. Too much focus on self and ones 'rights' (no one has rights, they have privileges) 2. Too distracted by the world. 3. Too much fous on what your friends are doing ( she's soo lucky she is free from kids all day and can do what she likes. When I'm stuck still home with my kids. Etc...) 4: not enough attention on God and His word. 5: not enough focus on serving others. 6 materialism. 7: ungratefullness. 8: rebellion against ones husband. Granted some husbands ask their wives to work. But I am yet to meet one housewife that was doing everything she old to create a Godly home and offspring and yet was no happy at home and said it 'didn't work for her'. Just that one statement oozed selfishness. EVERY housewife I have spoken to ( and I have spoken to many) who was not happy at home 9 times out of 10 met one of the above criteria at least.

Otherwise great post, as always Lori!
2 replies · active 543 weeks ago
One thing I feel so bad about is how society (as a whole) just expects our daughters to go to college and get a degree then pursue that career full force. I have a daughter (we school at home) that is in her junior year of high school. Numerous times this year, she has been asked "where are you going to college" or "have you decided on a college yet?" These questions are terribly presumptuous, and downright rude in my opinion. This puts her on the spot and makes her feel completely inadequate, that, despite being a straight A student, she does not intend or desire to go to college. Her desire is to fulfill the Lord's calling on her life to be a wife and mother. No, she doesn't have a boyfriend yet. She is praying for her future husband though, that the Lord is preparing him (whoever he may be) to be a Godly leader, provider, protector and father when they eventually do meet, date/court, and eventually marry. I've heard people tell her she should be a teacher so she can be at home with her children when they are at home! (They assume she'll send her children off to school I guess.) They tell her she really NEEDS a career and that she may be making a mistake by not pursuing college. To make matters worse, I think every single one of these folks who have asked her such questions are in our church or in other Christian churches...mostly, these aren't people from the "secular" world...It's SO discouraging. I just pray that she continues to follow her calling and relies on Christ for the endurance and courage to do so.

Lori, your blog is a tremendous encouragement for us. I share many of your posts with her and we've found many other good blogs linked from yours with articles and posts relating to specifically where she is in her life. You're such a blessing. Thank you!
3 replies · active 420 weeks ago

Post a new comment

Comments by