Friday, November 25, 2011

Harry Potter And Witchcraft


My children were not allowed to read these books or see the movies. I know witchcraft is sin and I didn't want any part of it.

Ken and I were walking the other day and I asked him his thoughts about the Harry Potter books and movies. He didn't really have a strong opinion either way. He pointed out that we watched The Wizard Of Oz growing up, along with a lot of Disney movies that had witchcraft in them.

The Lion, The Witch, And The Wardrobe has witchcraft in it. Most of these movies do portray a struggle between good and evil where good triumphs.

My question: Just because we watch a movie with some witchcraft in it, does that mean we are participating in it?

I used to love the television series called Monk. Every show started out with a murder. Was I participating in that murder, because I was watching it? I think not. The Bible has a lot of stories with murder and evil in them. So where do we draw the line?

I asked my 29 year old son what he thought since he read them last year and this is what he replied: "Yes, I will allow my kids to read them when age appropriate, probably middle school age. I've read them and found them to be very well written and entertaining. I don't think they're too different from Lord of the Rings since good triumphs over evil." He did tell me that the later books are darker so he wouldn't let his children read them until they were a bit older.

I think this is just another gray area where everyone has to be convicted in their own mind and seek God's wisdom. I am very convicted about not watching movies with immodesty, sex, and a lot of foul language. We are commanded to dwell on the lovely, good, and pure.  But I am sure I can watch a good murder mystery or fantasy movie and not sin.

This is why we have to be so careful in judging others. God doesn't spell everything out in black and white. He sent His Holy Spirit to live inside of us to convict and encourage us. We must listen to him and know God's Word. We need to be sensitive to live our lives for the Lord, which means earnestly loving others and doing good.

I am sure there are godly children out there who have seen Harry Potter movies and are not involved in witchcraft. I just didn't feel comfortable with them, especially as society around us gets darker and darker. I want my light to shine brightly...not by judging others in issues that are not clearly spelled out in Scripture, however, but living my life pleasing to Him.

The faith which you have, have as your own conviction before God. Happy is he who does not condemn himself in what he approves
Romans 14:22

***My book "The Power of the Transformed Wife" is on sell for $12.48!

Comments (20)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
I like the direction you took with this post. Grace to you. Sometimes we can have blind spots when we set a standard for others to attain who are being led in other ways more clearly by God and not being spoken to at the time on a specific matter that we feel strongly about. God is able to speak to each of His own by His Spirit. The truth in love...or not at all.
Dawn
I avoided these books and movies for a few years - and then I read one -just to see what the hoop-la was about - and in the reading, I really saw what kids are crying out for, what they need, how they feel. I let the boys watch the movies and read the books - but we discussed the actions of those in the movies with what God said in the bible. We even discussed how she lifted SSSSOOOOooooo much from Tolkien and in the discussion, I think we de-fanged issues they might be tempted with as they got older - because we used these ideas to delved into the bible and understand why God said, "No."

However, there's a time and a season to approach these ideas - and we have to do what we think is right - because it is right for that particular place and time - like you decided. As a parent, we control what our kids see - and don't want to be swept away with the popularity tide before we know what we're dealing with.
http://bluecottonmemory.wordpress.com/2009/07/26/...
I loved math too, Paul. It has always been my favorite subject. I was also a black and white person and was very judgmental of others. As I have matured in my faith, I give a lot more grace and realize that there are indeed gray areas! I share my opinions and then let others have theirs.
I didn't let my children watch these when they were little. And, shamefully, it started out being for judgmental reasons, pious reasons.

But, at the same time, I remember the author stating in an interview that the books were really never intended for children and that each book got more dark. I have also always tried to follow the general rule that if the rest of the world is obsessed with it, then I should shy away from it. Oprah Winfrey, Twilight, Harry Potter, The South Beach Diet, you get the drift. It has served me well to have this attitude. Maybe I'm a non-conformist at heart. Or maybe I really do try to take the road less traveled.

In any event, my two older kids are 15 and 17 now. They have seen some of the movies, but are not obsessed with it. My little two, ages 7 and 6, haven't ever asked about it (other than wanting toys they see on commercials) and they have been happy with my response that there are millions of toys out there to purchase, and we will just choose toys that don't glamorize witchcraft.

But, if someone else wants to watch it and read it, that is their business.
I love your thoughts on this. Especially the connection with murder-mysteries -- most plots involve sin. I don't think that means we are likely to fall for that sin.

But I am totally keeping my kids away from darker fantasy until their understanding of fact and fiction is very well developed -- including their understanding that witchcraft is indeed something real (that might or might not have characteristics in common with fictional representations that share the same vocabulary).
Great post! I was in college and in a very complacent walk with the Lord when Harry Potter hit the scene and I didn't understand why some religious folk were going nuts over it. I was just happy that Harry Potter got kids wanting to read! (I was an English major.) Through the years, I've read all the books, seen some of the movies, and although a compelling coming of age story, I now see the problems in glamorizing witchcraft and I probably won't let my daughter read it. Over these last two years as I've grown spiritually, I have also felt convicted over things I watch on tv and have set a standard for myself that I won't watch any R material anymore. Garbage in, garbage out. I'm just not interested anymore.
We also avoid those movies. However, my children are starting to become huge fans of Star Wars. I have heard controversy over those movies as well. I will admit to being a big fan of Star Wars.
What a fabulous post. So very true, and I love that you point out it is up to the Holy Spirit within us to guide us and give us discernment. We are NOT to judge others for their decisions. The Bible is also very clear about that as well.

Thanks for sharing.
P.S. My mom never let me watch them either....and I turned out just fine without them. :)
We are HUGE Harry Potter fans but not because of the wizarding part of it, more like in spite of it. We consider it a story about good triumphing over evil. It shows that there is good and bad in all of us and our character depends on whether we choose to do good or bad. My kids know that wizards/witches do not exist and it has never been an issue. My kids picked up on the fact that Harry was willing to give his life for those he loved and that he struggled with making the right decisions just as everyone does. There are parts of the books that every single person can identify with (feelings of insecurity, sense of loss, the ability to hold onto hope, etc). Thank you for not condemning those of us who choose to read/watch fantasy. So many believe that there is only one way (their way!) and anyone who doesn't conform is wrong. This is the number one reason I love your blog-there is no condemnation. And those readers who responded show that they just as non judgemental of those who think differently. Wish more people could be like that....
My mother gave my son the set of books when he was younger and he and I read them together. I personally love them! I think the stories are great and good triumphs over evil. I agree with the limiting the tv and movie watching. I think a person can be de-sensitized with the junk that's put out these days. Harry Potter and his friends are much tamer viewing than 3/4 of whats on television.
For the record I've read the books and love the movies. My girls watch them too. I explain to them that it isn't real, just made up characters, there is no such thing as flying broomsticks and dragons and giant spiders the size of houses. And considering i am a writer and enjoy writing ya fantasy, I don't mind. Good triumphs over evil. My kids aren't conjuring up Spells. As a Christian and a writer I have struggled with this at first. But i personally prayed about it, and felt peace aboubthe issue. we are all given unique talents and if I enjoy writing about "fake" made up magic dragons and flying i assume its better than what much of what the other popular ya books hold, such as sex, underage drinking, drugs etc. Really its sickeing what is popular in ya fantasy. I don't write about any of these things as well as swearing (obviously!?! Since I do none of these myself!!). My kids haven't watched the pg 13 ones, and never actually seen a whole movie all the way through-just on tv. However I'm a huge fan and respect the creativity of another writer. I must tell you though our whole family does not even watch rated R movies. We attend church every Sunday, read scriptures as a family every night and have family prayer every day in addition to meal prayers and morning prayers. We have many ocasions in which we talk about choosing g the right and the difference between good and evil. Sorry for being so long....just a Chrsitian who enjoys writing fantasy and knows the difference real and fantasy.
Great post! I love Harry Potter so I was very interested in what this post was going to say :) Some things are just for entertainment only. It is super hard to try not to be judgemental about our own personal convictions though, I think it's something everyone struggles with.
I think that if Christians approach these gray areas with prayerful consideration and thought, the Spirit will give us discernment that will undoubtedly manifest into different courses of action for different Believers. That is fine.

What is bothersome, however, is the tendancy many Christians have to jump right into whatever the world's latest craze is without giving a single thought as to whether it is pleasing to the Lord.
I agree. Lots of gray area there. My perspective is why take the chance?
Our church discouraged Harry Potter, and one of the main reasons was that the way that one goes about getting a right or proper result should be achieved in a good and honest and integrous manner.
My DD has seen all the movies and read all the books. My ex and my DH are both ok with it.
Mommy of Two's avatar

Mommy of Two · 695 weeks ago

Hi Lori! I enjoy your posts and look forward to getting them in my Google reader. You bring up an important questions for Christians to consider. I have been considering this question more seriously that my little girls are growing up and showing interest in Disney cartoons. After reading and meditating on Deutoronomy 18:9-13 I came to the conclusion that God has a pretty defenite stance on magic, witchcraft and similar things. They are called "abomination Unto the Lord" and i think its only reasonable to assume He wants us to have the same viewpoint.
As I see it, this area is not gray in God's eyes rather it is Satan that wants us to think this area gray. It is evident by all the magic and witchcraft that is masterly interwoven in so many children's cartoons and programs. It all seems so harmless! A magic want here, a spell there. What's the big deal?
Apparently it is a big deal to God. Deut 18:12 says "For all that do these things [are] an abomination unto the LORD: and because of these abominations the LORD thy God doth drive them out from before thee."
God is willing to drive these things away from us. The questions is will we let him?
1 reply · active 418 weeks ago
Agreed mommy of two!!!!😇
Very good post on this subject! It can be a rough one sometimes, because it's so easy to make oneself appear to be (or reveal oneself as) a hypocrite or a Pharisee. You handled it very well, and left it open-ended enough that it wasn't telling people what to think, but caused us to think nevertheless. Kudos!
After much prayer and reading of what God says about Witchcraft my husband and I took the stand not to allow any movies or books with wizards or witches or magic allowed in our homes- including Disney. It was a hard choice because it is EVERYWHERE. The hardest part of this conviction is not hurting other people's feelings, because we don't want to judge them- it is just our personal family rule. When Frozen came out, no, my kids could not watch it, when they were given The Lion THE WITCH and the wardrobe we donated it to Goodwill. Harry Potter is not allowed either. I don't feel like my kids are missing out I just want to be sensitive to others and not appear judgemental, it's just what we have chosen for us. Thanks for the post.

Post a new comment

Comments by