Saturday, July 13, 2013

Are Midwives Safer Than Doctors?


During pregnancy, women in Britain are taken care of my midwives.  They greatly encourage natural childbirth.  They believe the less intervention, the healthier it is for mother and baby.  They only like to give Pitocin, epidurals, C-sections, etc. if they are medically necessary for the health of the mother or the baby. I heard this on the news while they were discussing the birth of Princess Kate.

Britain's National Institute for Health and Excellence has found, "It is safer for healthy women with uncomplicated pregnancies to give birth under the supervision of midwives than in a hospital maternity wards run by doctors. The reason: doctors are much more likely than midwives to use interventions like forceps deliveries, spinal anesthesia and cesarean sections ~ procedures that carry risk of infection and surgical accidents."

Contrast that to America. Most doctors encourage epidurals. Some women schedule C-sections so having a baby won't interfere too much with their lives. Pitocin is routinely given, etc.  The rate of C-sections is three times higher in America than in Britain percentage wise.

I had my first two babies completely natural and the last two I had an epidural. I recovered much quicker from the first two than the last two.  With any medical procedure, you are taking a risk. Look carefullly at the side effects and warnings for Pitocin, epidurals, and C-sections.

Yes, it hurts. It hurts a lot but the less medical intervention you need, the better.  God designs women's bodies to give birth. Most women can give birth without medical intervention. However, I praise God for medical intervention when needed. It has saved many lives.

When you are preparing for childbirth, you must train yourself to keep your mind focused on the Lord and His strength.  Memorize Bible verses to give you comfort and encouragement.  Billions of women have given birth before and have survived. You can do it also!

Allowing your body to do what it was meant to do without drugs or surgery should always be your first line of action, whether it is having a baby or healing from sickness or disease.

Do not be anxious about anything, 
but in everything, by prayer and petition, 
with thanksgiving, present your requests to God. 
Philippians 4:6

Comments (11)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
Love this! We took Hypnobirthing classes with our second pregnancy, and one thing we discussed was what birth looks like around the world. Britain being one of them. Like you, I am very thankful that we have OB's who can help and get babies out very fast when needed for the child or mommy, but it is way overdone.

Even with midwives. Our third child (second pregnancy) I had a very knowledgeable, experienced midwife and we had an AMAZING home birth experience. It was so nice to be able to just have a baby and go in any room or any position I wanted to go. I never had to worry about packing bags, going to the hospital, checking in, having nurses constantly come in as I'm trying to focus and more. My husband I just loved being right in our own bed as we stared at our new blessing minutes after birth.

We had to move states and I can't have a home birth (unless we did it illegally or with no midwife) and with #4 on the way I'm having to accept the fact that another hospital birth is my reality. It's hard, but I'm determined to make it a good one. We are having a doula, something I would recommend if you want a natural childbirth in the hospital. The doula knows our birth plan, and all questions are directed to her. This allows me to focus on each contraction, and it allows by husband to focus on being right there as a supportive coach instead of veering off alternatives.

I had an epidural with my first. I also healed and felt 10x better afterwards when I had my second baby boy (1 1/2 lbs bigger) naturally.
I agree that natural childbirth is better. However, one must be careful of the midwife they choose. Not all are knowledgeable. I planned a home birth with my first and had a local midwife. But she assumed my labor would take a long, long time and when she heard I had been up all night laboring, she told me to take Benadryl and get some sleep. That was a BAD idea. It stalled my labor and I ended up in labor for 2 days without going anywhere. Previously it was progressing well. Due to total exhaustion and risk of infection, after 2 days I had to go to the hospital and get pitocin and an epidural and finally delivered my daughter after 54 hours in labor. But she and I needed antibiotics and there were other complications that would not have happened if I hadn't taken the midwife's advice. So be careful who you choose and get someone who knows something about real medicine.
The birth system in America is definitely messed up! I have had 2 of my children with an epidural, and one of them naturally (not planned that way, but she came so fast there was no choice! Her time of birth was 8 minutes after arriving at the hospital!) I have to say that my recovery from the natural birth was worlds easier than the epidural births. Not only that, but I had a natural high right afterwards, whereas with my epidural births I didn't get that as much. I've been blessed with three wonderful births and three healthy babies, which is the goal of course, but I have to admit the natural birth was better. I felt so close to God afterwards, and felt like He could help me get through anything. I wouldn't do a home birth but for my next baby I want to go the natural route again!
(Side note: an added bonus is that my natural delivery hospital bill was next to nothing!)
I gave birth to my two boys naturally, with no medical intervention. The second one was a bit scary and they had to give me an IV just in case more intervention was necessary. I was fine with it. Although both deliveries hurt more than I ever could have imagined, what I like about drug-free births is when it's over, it's over! Once that baby is out, you're done! With an epidural, there is still recovery time. After both of my boys were born, I truly felt fantastic! I got out of bed pretty quickly, showered, made myself up a little, and felt like I could run a marathon. Both boys were very good nursers right from the get-go as well and very, very alert. I won't sugarcoat it-natural childbirth hurts A LOT, but it truly is worth it. If we have another child, no question, it will be natural. And considering my 2nd labor was 2 hours from start to finish, the next one will probably (but not necessarily) be very, very fast as well. Fast doesn't mean easy though:)
Thank you for this post. I agree with you. I think our health-care system does too much "unnatural intervention" in childbirth and we rely far too much on drugs, medications and surgery. This is a big reason that our health-care costs are totally out of control. I have had four children. I had two epidurals but felt MUCH better and recovered more quickly on the two when I did not have them. Pitocin is just nasty. I had that twice and hated it. Natural is much better. My oldest daughter has had two of her three natural and those two with a midwife and dula. It turned our very well for her. We need to have more women and doctors be willing to go along with midwives and even home birthing.
Lori, when I was in labor with my second baby, I was in a LOT of pain--then I got the epidural and immediately felt relief. Well, when I got the epidural, the relief made my heart rate drop (it had been very high with the pain--I'm an extremely sensitive person) but it also made my baby's heart rate drop. His rate dropped so much that the doctor decided that the only safe thing to do for the baby would be to take him out via C-section. I did NOT want to have surgery and was upset, so while I was in the OR being prepped, I started reciting Psalm 23 to myself. Fifteen minutes later, after receiving a spinal block and being completely prepped, my doctor decided to monitor his heart one more time, just in case. It started going back up! It was amazing--my son's heart rate went back up to normal, and my doctor said that the C-section was not necessary after all. I pushed him out 10 minutes later, and he was born within 30 minutes. God is amazing--he protected me and my baby boy, and He guided the hand of my doctor to truly protect me.
Thank you for sharing on Babies and Beyond! I've have two epidurals and one natural. The key for me was having a doula. But even with my natural delivery, the nurses were yelling at me to push and my body wasn't ready. If the Lord blesses us with another child, I would love to reread Supernatural Childbirth and really try to focus on specific Scripture verses.
In New Zealand, we have one of the best midwife systems in the world. We choose a midwife and they care for us during our pregnancy, birth and six-weeks postpartum. I developed a really close relationship with my midwife. After six weeks, our children are then cared for by an organisation called Plunket, with a nurse regularly caring for them until they are five years old. There is also a Well-Being nurse for the mum.
We have antenatal classes in the thrid trimester to prepare us for labour, and they push natural delivery. Every woman is asked what she would like and that's the way it goes, unless there is an emergency. I was quite happy to go with however it ended up, as my baby was big. I had no pain medication, but had a suction cup because after pushing for 2 1/2 hours I was so tired!! I think it's great here that we can choose, and if I needed medication in the future, I feel confident my midwife and doctors on hand would know what's best for me.
I am new to you blog and could not agree more with this. pregnant now with number 7
Thanks for sharing this post. Baby is a gift of God. Every woman need a baby. Even I also want. I am a upcoming mom. Now I am pregnant in 14 weeks. This is my first time. So I am so excited and little bit nervous also. This article helps to me .
I am extremely inspired with your writing skill. A must read article for every woman who are about to give a birth. Thanks for the share.

Post a new comment

Comments by