Wednesday, July 17, 2013

Too Much Time In School


When I put Steven into kindergarten, he would fall asleep at the dinner table.  He was absolutely exhausted.  I began picking him up at noon three days a week and brought him home for a nap.  Full days, I believe, are too long for five year olds.

Studies have proven that Children should spend less time in school.  I completely agree with this statement.  So much of time in school is busy work. Also, expecting boys to sit in chairs for such long periods of time is not good for them. 

When I homeschooled my boys, they would read for a couple hours a day, do an hour of math, and play a lot.  I liked my boys moving a lot.  I felt it was good for them.  People in Finland seem to agree with me ~

Children in Finland go outside to play frequently all day long. "How can you teach when the children are going outside every 45 minutes?" a recent American Fulbright grant recipient in Finland, who was astonished by how little time the Finns were spending in school, inquired curiously of a teacher at one of the schools she visited. The teacher in turn was astonished by the question. "I could not teach unless the children went outside every 45 minutes!"

The Finnish model of education includes a late start to academics {children do not begin any formal academics until they are 7 years old}, frequent breaks for outdoor time, shorter school hours and more variety of classes than in the US. Equity, not high achievement, is the guiding principle of the Finnish education system.

While we in America preach the mantra of early intervention, shave time off recess to teach more formal academics and cut funding to non-academic subjects like art and music, Finnish educators emphasize that learning art, music, home economics and life skills is essential. {Have American Parents Got It All Backwards}

Just because society is doing it one way doesn't mean it is right.  Way too many boys are being put on Ritalin since they have trouble sitting still for long periods.  Ryan use to have to miss recess because he was staring at the ceiling too long!  That was the last thing he needed.  He needed to go out and play.

But beyond this, my son, be warned:
the writing of many books is endless,
and excessive devotion to books is wearying to the body.
Ecclesiastes 12:12

Comments (12)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
I. Love. this. Entirely too many kids are put on ritalin and other adhd medicines, and I fully believe that most of them just need to be able to run around and play! Learning should be fun, not a drudge of sitting in a classroom for hours on end without a break.
Couldn't agree more. I truly believe the all day kindergarten concept has come about to accommodate all the working moms better. I babysit for a few children and as opposed to so many daycares I don't get into all the "structured learning" time. I do teach them as they play and I read to them. Little things like colors, numbers and shapes are easily incorporated into play time. I think it's more important for me to help them learn about God and virtues. I am very thankful that my parents are on the same page with me on this. Glad at least one country has it right in this area.
This is timely as our elementary school is switching from 1/2 day to full day kindergarten next year and I've been calling the district and talking to them about this. They admit that 90% of parents are asking for full day often because they don't want to pay for extra childcare. I think the 1/2 day program is perfect for 5 year olds. I am asking that they provide a 1/2 day option. My last baby won't be in school for another year and I am NOT sending her to full-day no matter what.
I'm so glad that kindergarten here is only half day and that my little boy who is starting school will be turning 6 a week into the school year! I'm going to miss him so much but I'm SO glad it's only for 2.5 hours a day. He'll be home by 11:30 AM and can have lunch with us and take a nap. I couldn't send him if it was all day, I really couldn't. But I completely agree with your post! I read that article about Finnish schools too. I wish America would wake up and do things differently with the school systems. I've considered homeschooling, but I don't think I'm cut out for it personally!
I am public school teacher and I agree with you. It seems like the harder we push our children, the more problems we have as a society. Once again, it goes back to the family and the decline of traditional family life in our nation. We have to have school last longer and longer because parents work so much. School becomes a "baby-sitting service" in many ways. Many schools do not teach accountability, responsibility or character and unfortunately many parents do not either. We need to begin with a return to God and strong famlies to fix education and everything else going wrong in our society.
Totally agree!!
Could not agree more! One more reason why we have chosen to homeschool our children. I have 2 3-year-olds, and I'm already getting questioned about what preschool curriculum I'm going to do with them. They are still babies! We have decided to go over a book list, and they have learned so much from just reading. We also go over basics, but I definitely don't think they need anything formal at all. We spend about 30 minutes a day reading and that's "school" for us. Then they have lots and lots of free-time to play. Their imagination is just amazing!
Wonderful post!
Kathy Davenport's avatar

Kathy Davenport · 609 weeks ago

I'm a retired public school teacher. What most people don't know is that mandatory public education as we know it was started simply to control the populace. The time factors, regimentation, being ruled by the "bells," and even sitting in rows prepared children for their future working in factories and other regimented positions. Another purpose, especially for immigrants and Native Americans, was to make certain they spoke and thought like everyone else and were taken away from the "evil influences" of their own cultures.

Also as a teacher, I can attest to the person who said these longer daily schedules are for the benefit/convenience of the parents. Parents were always the ones most upset if the school day was shortened or cancelled for any reason, including bad weather.
Right on! Our schools working are to teach critical thinking in the classroom, when nothing teaches critical thinking better than play! Give kids a big sandbox some shovels and buckets- they'll create, build, problem solve, and interact. Too bad we seek artificial means to teaching skill children can learn naturally.
I work in public education in Milwaukee and it's not just classroom time - we have parents that purposely choose a school on the opposite end of town just to keep their kids on the busses longer - i.e. more free daycare.

In defense of these parents, I do want to point out that in many Europeean countries, EMPLOYERS are far more understanding of working parents than American employers are. Maternity leaves are much longer, more employers allow work from home options, and more employers allow flexible worktimes. Working parents in other countries have a much easier time taking off when their kids are sick or being able to schedule their work hours around their child's school hours. Perhaps school days wouldn't need to be so long in the States if employers were more flexible!
With all due respect ma'am, do you have sources or studies (scientific journals) which tells us that kids need to spend less time in school? For sake of integrity and honesty.

Jesus Bless!!

Post a new comment

Comments by