Wednesday, January 25, 2012

Women Pastors


Danielle commented on one of my posts concerning women with children being keepers at home the following ~

So then I guess your stance would be that there shouldn't be any woman pastors, evangelists, missionaries, teachers, prophetesses, etc.? Because all of those roles would be outside of the home? No where in the Bible does it limit those positions/titles to men.

I believe the Bible does limit the role of pastor to men.  Read I Timothy carefully and Paul's instruction to the church. 

The first thing he writes to the leaders of the church is, "This is a true saying, If a MAN desire the office of a bishop, he desires a good work..." 
{I Timothy 3:1}.

To bishops he writes, "A bishop then must be blameless, the HUSBAND of one wife..." 
{I Timothy 3:2}. 

To deacons he writes, "Even so must their wives be grave...Let the deacons be the HUSBANDS of one wife..." 
{I Timothy 3:11}. 

He also writes concerning order in worship, "But I suffer not a woman to teach, nor to usurp authority over the man, but to be in silence" 
{I Timothy 2:12}.

All throughout the Bible, men are the leaders...Moses, Noah, Abraham, Paul, Jesus, etc.  Sure there was Queen Esther, but she was married to a King.  God definitely used women in powerful ways to accomplish his goals and puts the same worth upon women as a man, He just gave us different roles.

Most men are stronger physically and emotionally.  They don't have to deal with PMS and menopause.  God's ways are good.  They are for women's protection. 

I am sure I will hear from some of you about how wrong I am, but please use Scripture to back up your arguments.  That is what I base all of my beliefs upon.  I never want to water it down to fit my lifestyle or what society tells me is right.  I enjoy hearing other's viewpoints and am always open to learning.

Comments (86)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
Amen! I was blind on this issue for many years. Becuase I NEVER really took the time to search the scriptures. After reading Created my eyes were open to the truth in God's word. Woman think this limits them..NOT SO! It is true freedom!
God's ways are best. Keep speaking truth.
Blessings!
Carla <><
I must say AMEN also! What a blessing it is when we follow what the scriptures have to say. God's ways are the best and life is such a blessing when we follow what He says.
Joyfully,
Cheryl
I also completely agree. I Timothy 2:12 was the verse that came to my mind immediately. How much more clear can you be that women are not to rule over nor teach to a man? There are so many other ways women can be used....just not in positions over men.
I definitely agree. I think being a Pastor is a MANS calling. I don't think many men would be receptive to being taught and convicted by a woman. I think that women can do great things in womens ministry and are called to encourage and uplift other women. I always tell my daughter you can do anything you want...except be a Pastor or President :)
Is it your place to be interpreting Scripture? Men -- men! -- who have studied Scripture have allowed women to become pastors. It is not your place to question them--the Bible states this clearly.
1 reply · active 687 weeks ago
I found your site today and put it into my favorites. I homeschool my daughter and she wants to be a stay at home mom someday. I try to use blogs that a like minded to help teach her Bibical womanhood. So thanks.
Amy, JJJ, & stacy please quit picking on her for HER beliefs. If you don't like them don't read the blog. All you want to do is argue.
2 replies · active 687 weeks ago
Two words: cultural context

I believe that the Scriptures are God's Word, through the lens of the world and society as it was over 2000 years ago.

My take on Scripture is contextual; meaning that I respect the teachings and themes given through the bible, but I do not accept it as correct word for word.

Textualism, or following the Bible to the letter of the text is another respected approach to the Scriptures.

In my view, our overarching beliefs are the same, even if the details of the practice of our faith may be quite different. However, generally speaking, I am not going to be able to give you a specific cite to a passage that I think agrees with me more than you, because you and I will probably often disagree as to the meanings of particular passages.
I had a friend who was a female pastor. She has moved from church to church to church. Any church she is at starts experiencing major troubles. I agree with you, Lori. As far as CAN a woman be a preacher/president? Sure! But SHOULD she? Women make far too many emotionally based decisions! Cultural Context? I've studied Hebrew/Judiasm for a long time now. The women were not allow to preach/pray/speak in church. Not because they were being put down, but because God places such a high emphasis on motherhood and wifehood. They believe the a woman's job as mother and wife are so important, that they should not be pulled away. I don't think God changes, nor do his view points. I believe that's why it is said "the same yesterday, today and forever". People today just have a hard time accepting the Bible might say something other than what our culture does, so we have to fit it around our beliefs, rather than our beliefs around the Bible.
6 replies · active 687 weeks ago
Lori,
I understand how this message is difficult for many women to swallow because I used to be like them. Thanks be to God, I now know the truth: God's word is the same now as it always was and will ever be ~ His mind doesn't change with the times, His ways are best, His message is true, and you teach it here so well. The resistance to your scripture-based posts is proof, in my opinion, of their validity. God bless you and the TRUTH, salt, and light that you through this blog bring to your readers.
Adrienne Dixon's avatar

Adrienne Dixon · 687 weeks ago

I'' ve yet to see those opposing this topic reference scripture.. The bible is clear about women in authority.

Thanks, Lori for being such an awesome mentor and example of a godly wife and mother! I am so blessed by you and Learn so much!!
3 replies · active 687 weeks ago
I am so thankful to have found you! I am learning and reading alot now!
Whilst I strongly believe that women should have a choice in regards to working or remaining at home, I strongly believe that women should not be preaching in churches based on I Timothy 2:12. However I don't have any problems with women in supporting roles in the church such as running groups of mothers, women, the elderly etc... but not preaching the word of God as the Bible is very clean on this. Lori, I agree with you on this. I am not sure if women are asked to keep quiet because we are more emotional or ramble far too much - as the Bible doesn't spell that out.
Lori,
I'm with you on women as pastors and elders. But please tell me what you think about Pheobe the deaconess we see in Romans 16:1.
7 replies · active 687 weeks ago
Lively and interesting discussion. A full and complete set of answers to many of the questions raised in this comments section can be found at http://carm.org/women-in-ministry.

I believe that any serious student of the Word will concluded that the apostle Paul fully intended for women to not be elders, pastor/teachers, or to teach men in the church, or exercise authority over a men in the church. Paul’s argument’s for this are not cultural but an appeal to order that he believed God desires in the church. Paul also clearly taught that women were to be silent in the church, and yet most churches allow women to speak in giving announcements and praying, and for good reason. These same churches do not generally allow women to teach from the pulpit or exercise authority as elders in the church because this is clearly forbidden by Paul’s writings.

It is a recent phenomenon to find churches that have women pastors and elders. These churches argue that what Paul is saying is cultural and Paul could not have anticipated the cultural revolution of our time where men and women are not only equal, their roles and lines of authority are completely blurred. It seems this argument does not leave much room for the Spirit’s inspiration knowing that the scriptures would transcend all cultures.

For those who want to jump to head coverings must be worn and women are not to speak at all in the church if one is to take Paul literally, I suggest that one look at the possible damage caused to the church if women speak in church or come with heads uncovered; verses the damage that arises if indeed God truly intends as His Word teaches that women as not to be pastor/teachers. If the church gets it wrong that head covering were cultural the damage is minimal, but if the church gets it wrong allowing for women pastor/teachers, and God’s true intent is exactly what Paul teaches, then the damage can be great indeed. Also, consider the “weight of scripture” when arguing any point too dogmatically. If the scriptures mention head coverings once, yet spends many words describing the structure of the church in multiple places, one should not give the two the same weight. The number of times that something is addressed in the scriptures often shows the importance God placed on our understanding and obeying it.

Do not believe that the scriptures are opposed to the concept of women “pastors” in the modern church so long as they fulfill the Pauline directive of not exercising authority over a man or teaching a man in the church. Of course Paul would not have called them “pastors” as he reserved that term for elders who shepherd the flock. Women “pastors” can lead children’s ministry, teen ministries, women ministries and a myriad of other ministries that do not teach men or become elders. If one wants to call these women pastors, or deacons, it is fine. Women play a huge role in the church and run a vast number of ministries. Without women ministering most churches would be debilitated. But there are many great reasons why God intends for men to lead the church, and this should not be taken as man’s superiority in any way. Paul says it is God’s order of things. Imagine what happens to churches if men are not in leadership and teaching. Some of the results can already be seen as these same churches as now they begin to openly advocate gay clergy and gay marriage. Once the church begins to throw out Paul’s clear teaching the slippery slope of picking and choosing what is God’s Word quickly leads to apostasy. What do you think happened to most of the Ivy League schools and many Christian denominations? Do you think it by accident that they quickly fall away from anything familiar to those of us who choose to believe all of God’s Word?

So if you have a woman “pastor” that you love, or you enjoy listening to a woman pastor because she is a terrific speaker and expositor of God’s Word, keep in mind as you listen that talent in and of itself does not overcome God’s desire for men to be the pastor/teachers/elders in the church. Talent and effectiveness are human qualities, and if God’s design is that men should lead the church and feed the church, then this talented and effective pastor is causing more damage to her church than benefit. Unfortunately, such damage to the pastor, her family and her church may not be seen for many years. And… by God’s grace, God may very well choose to use in a mighty way some women pastors, as he uses all of us, even when disobedient, to accomplish His will and desires as He grows His Kingdom here on earth. Sorry for the long post…
3 replies · active 687 weeks ago
Hmm...this is a toughy! I totally agree with you that women are not to be the head pastors of a church, but women can definitely have the gift of shepherding and leadership (very different, I know).
I agree that women should not be pastors/president. I'm curious what your thoughts are on a woman being a children's pastor?
1 reply · active 687 weeks ago
Awesome post Lori!
You are very brave. I've seen you receive hard comments for things you post and you don't let that stop you from speaking truth.
I wish I had my Debbie Pearl book at hand to quote how beautifully she puts it and how clearly our rebellion and pride comes from our sinful nature when we choose to ignore God's design for women.
I get snide remarks from my own family when I tell them I'll homeschool my children. Snide remarks from friends and coworkers when I say: I'll ask my husband's permission.
But I will stand before God and know I chose to follow Him.

What is your point of view on women being leaders in church exclusively to other women? Would this too be usurping men's role?
1 reply · active 687 weeks ago
Romans 16:1: Paul refers to Phoebe as a minister or deacon of the church at Cenchrea. The Greek word which describes her function is "diakonos" which means literally "official servant." She is the only deacon in the Bible to be identified by name. Some translations say "deaconess;" others try to obscure her position by mistranslating the Greek as a simple "servant" or "helper". Paul later refers to Phoebe as a woman, calling her "our sister."
Exodus 15:24: Miriam, the daughter of Aaron was a prophet and one of the triad of leaders of Israel during the Exodus from Egypt.

Judges 4 & 5: Deborah, a prophet-judge, headed the army of ancient Israel.

2 Kings 22:14; 2 Chronicles 34:22 Huldah, a prophet, verified the authenticity of the "Book of the Law of the Lord given through Moses" - the Book of Deuteronomy. She triggered a religious renewal.
Prisca or Priscilla (16:3-5) was in ministry along with her husband Aquila. They are called fellow-workers, a term of equality elsewhere used of Paul and Apollos (1Cor. 3:9). When the couple is mentioned in writing, Priscilla's name is listed first, indicating that she may have been the leader of the two.
1 reply · active 687 weeks ago
Luke 11:31
English Standard Version (ESV)

31 The queen of the South will rise up at the judgment with the men of this generation and condemn them, for she came from the ends of the earth to hear the wisdom of Solomon, and behold, something greater than Solomon is here.
Cross references:Luke 11:31 : 1 Kgs. 10:1; 2 Chr. 9:1Luke 11:31 : Heb. 11:7; [Jer. 3:11; Ezek. 16:51, 52; Rom. 2:27]Luke 11:31 : [Matt. 12:6]
2 replies · active 687 weeks ago
There are many different people in different roles in the Bible. King Solomon had many wives. Does that mean men can have many wives? God gives us many commands in the New Covenant that He expects His people to follow. Show me some verses in the New Covenant that specifically say that women can and should be leaders in the church? I believe they can be leaders in the workforce and politics, but Paul is very clear about His order in the church.
6 replies · active 687 weeks ago
I totally agree with Lori. The Bible is very clear that God is the head of man and man is the head of woman. I love that line up personally. God's ways do not change with time.
Lori, I completely agree with you! Even though it is still hard for me -- I was a lawyer whom God called to seminary (M.Div. program). I was an excellent student, preacher and teacher. Then I married and submitted to my husband's view of the Bible's teaching -- It was convincing! Now I am a stay-at-home mother, doing some teaching/leading in women's Bible studies.

It is "natural" (i.e. from my upbringing/education/culture) to be a strong leader. I believe my impact in God's Kingdom work will be greater, though, from submitting, raising my kids etc. rather than preaching etc. God is shaping my character through motherhood.

Submission brings peace. I know many godly, talented women pastors. They are sincere but I think their lives are more challenging than God would have them . . .

Post a new comment

Comments by