Tuesday, June 18, 2013

Dealing With A Daughter's Weight


Diet and weight are huge issues in our society.  Huge!  I read HERE how you should never say about yourself that you are fat and ugly in the presence of your daughter or her life and body image will be ruined forever.  The author ended the article with ~

Let us honour and respect our bodies for what they do instead of despising them for how they appear. Focus on living healthy and active lives, let our weight fall where it may, and consign our body hatred in the past where it belongs. 

Then I read THIS where the author responded to something posted on Facebook.
The post on Facebook ~ If I ever have a daughter:  She will always know how gorgeous she is.  There will be no scales in the house.  The words 'diet' and 'fat' will be like swear words.  I never want her feeling like I do.  The author responded in her article with ~

If you are going to try and control something, control what your child eats so they don't get fat in the first place.  Teach them good eating habits, teach them to adhere to a healthy diet.  That will save them far more grief than turning the words "fat" and "diet" into swear words.  They won't have a bad connotation if you don't let your daughters get fat.

This is not an easy subject.  We were careful with what our children ate when they were younger.  I fed them very healthy food and wanted them to play outside a lot.  We wouldn't let them eat much junk nor would we let them overeat.  We were definitely considered "strict parents."

As our daughters got older, if we thought they were gaining weight, we would talk to them about it.  I know this is supposedly a "taboo" subject but we felt no subject was "taboo" with our children.  If we saw any sin in their lives, we would talk to them about it.

Do they think we did it the right way?  I am not sure.  I am not sure there is an exactly right way to handle this situation.  Food  and weight are extremely sensitive subjects but I don't think they should be avoided.  Most men do like women who are in shape.  Not necessarily thin but in shape and healthy.  Being at a decent weight is much healthier also.

Each couple must seek wisdom in this area but I think it should definitely be talked about, modeled, and confronted in your children's lives.  Even if you do everything right, they may struggle with their weight since we live in a society of abundance and junk food everywhere.  We are admonished to be known for our moderation, however.  This is a good quality to teach your children.

Let your moderation be known unto all men. 
The Lord is at hand.
Philippians 4:5



Comments (11)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
I have three super-skinny kids, and our last, a girl age 7, is built shorter, stockier and heavier. Over the past couple of years she started gradually gaining weight, especially in her stomach. She has always had gassy issues and her pediatrician would tell me how her stomach was distended because of it. This past year, though, i really noticed her gaining weight around her neck and in her face. That's when I decided I had to take action.

I knew that it was not HER job to control her weight, but mine as her mom. I knew that my job was to teach her early how to make good choices in her diet and physical activity. I don't feel like discussing weight gain as a problem is wrong. It is a problem. I wanted my daughter to know that we were going to figure out what foods her body responded to the best, because we are all different and have different needs.

I read the book Ending the Food Fight by David Ludwig. It was excellent! It made sense to me so I started implementing it's ideas. We because strict about her eating all five food groups, eating higher proteins, lower carbs, less starches, more vegetables, concentrating on lower glycemic foods. Thankfully we have never been a family that drinks much other than water, milk, and the occasional juice, so this wasn't a battle I had to fight. I took out all pre-packaged snacks and started making homemade cookies, muffins, etc., with a healthy spin on it. We realized that she also had some lactose intolerance and irritable bowel syndrome, so factored that into her diet.

Now that it is summer her physical activity is a lot more, which helps a lot. She loves to ride her scooter, swim, and his playing softball.

Recently I started reading the book Trim Healthy Mama. I was thrilled to see that it follows the same premise as Ending the Food Fight, so it's a diet we are all on as a family.

I am proud to say that my daughter's weight is now under control and she is feeling and looking so much better! She shows me her tummy all the time and says, "Look how healthy my tummy looks." She is still a bigger girl, still shorter, still stockier, still heavier. And she always will be, more than likely, but she now knows how to make healthy food choices and knows what too many carbs and sugars does to her body.

Education is key. And honesty, in my humble opinion.
I would like to encourage you to continue to learn more about a healthy weight and the science behind it. How we talk to our daughters is important and I thank you for encouraging healthy eating and living in your blog post.

While there is a major problem in our culture with overeating and eating junk food, please don't fall into the trap that food and exercise are the primary cause for a healthy or unhealthy weight. There is so much more involved in having a healthy weight. Our bodies, to be healthy, need to have a correct balance of hormones such as adrenaline, cortisol, and insulin. Thyroid levels have a major impact on weight as well. Another issue can be the result of even a single antibiotic treatment which can change the balance of bacteria in our guts and can cause cravings for sugars and carbs. Sleep, stress, exercise, and medication affect our health and the ability to gain or lose weight. Did you know that high or low cortisol levels will not allow you to burn fat no matter how much you eat or move!

Our heredity has a lot to do with it as well. At a doctor visit years ago, I was told to watch what I fed my off the chart for height and weight 2 year old boy until he came to my 6 year old daughter who was under the 25th percentile for height and weight. He told me to forget what he had just said about diet! They both have learned now how to have a healthy weight, but they need to live it out as well.

Keep on encouraging us! I appreciate all that you do!
I have found that most girls get slightly chunkier right before puberty. I've even seen this in many boys. So I wouldn't say anything to a child who was experiencing body changes. I would moreso just make sure the right things are happening without them even knowing. If we eat good food as a family, it won't be an issue. If the kids are involved in sports or whatever, it won't be an issue and their body will be what it is meant to be.

I wish there was a blog out there called "What health looks like" and would feature people who are runners or cyclists or swimmers or aerobic instructors and the world would see that people who are fit do not necessarily look like the "fitness health model" that is used to sell equipment.
1 reply · active 610 weeks ago
Amen!! Health comes in many shapes and sizes! Not all skinny people are necessarily healthy.
Thank you for this open and honest discussion of your experience with your daughters and weight as they were growing up. This is a challenging topic that may not have a one-approach-fits-all solution for every teenage girl. Mentioning a slight weight-gain to an easy going girl is completely different than mentioning such a weight-gain to a hyper-critical, type A girl who probably has already been analyzing every bodily imperfection and may be engaging in, or considering engaging in, disordered eating and unhealthy body image behaviors. It is interesting that in your verbiage, you equate weight gain with a sin issue. Certainly, gluttony, vanity, coveting another's body, and abusing your body with too much or too little food or exercise are sin issues. When I was a teen, if my mother saw me engaging in a behavior such as overeating, skipping meals, spending too much time obsessing over my physical appearance or comparing myself to others (I grew up in a dance studio, this was a common occurrence), she would discuss my sinful behaviors with me. Left unchecked, these sinful behaviors could result in unhealthy physical changes (weight gain/loss), but she never framed the issue as a change in my appearance, she always framed the conversation as addressing the unhealthy behavior she had witnessed (or suspected based on valid reasons). Maybe this would be different with an adult daughter (say, 25, for example) who is done growing and whose hormones should no longer be causing drastic physical changes. I live away from home now and my mom does not witness my food/fitness choices on a daily basis, so now if I gained an unhealthy amount of weight, she would say something to me. But ten years ago, the line of discussion was my behaviors themselves, and not the outward physical appearance they manifested.
I think a lot of it has to do with the approach that the parents take when talking to their children. Making "fat" negative is bad, while encouraging health is a positive way to approach the topic. Making certain foods taboo can backfire; however, making a family commitment to healthy eating and aerobic activity is not only a good way to deal with a child's weight, but also has the benefit of being a family building activity.

I am very careful not to let my daughter hear me talk negatively about my body (and I try not to talk negatively about my body in my own head) and I don't use the word diet. Instead we use the words "lifestyle" and "choices." Because she is a dancer I am hyper-aware of body issues. As her mom I try my best to keep out the negative influences while helping her develop her own sense of self-worth.
Hmmm my mom always teased us. But every single one of us kids chunked up around age 13 or so. We all grew out of it fortunately :) But I decided a long time ago, that if at all possible I wouldn't tease my children in that way.
I just wrote a post that went live on my blog today (modernishhomemaker.com) about why I no longer have a goal weight and in it I shared the story of how my mom's concern over my weight (before it was even a problem) really caused more stress for me, probably exacerbated the problem and caused a rift in our relationship that is still healing 18 years later. I will never forget the day my mom told me I ran like a fat girl. That put me off exercise as much or more than being picked on by my peers for my lack of athletic prowess in the games usually played in gym class. (I actually am pretty good at, and enjoy, tennis and dance and CrossFit (now), but those aren't the kind of activities you get to do in school) . . .

Based on my own experience my goal, should I ever have children, especially girls, is to NEVER mention their weight. instead we will only keep healthy food in the house. We won't use food as a reward (another thing I recently blogged about) and our family will enjoy physical activity together like family hikes, bike rides, catch and tennis. I'll keep plenty of information about healthy eating around and I hope to lead by example. But I will NOT do what my mother did - which was to harp on about my weight - it only made me feel worthless and even more stressed about it - to the point that it actually did become a problem. (when it first started it was the common weight gain the both girls and boys have before puberty starts - it was NOT, I repeat, NOT a problem when she first started picking at it - but it became a problem and a scar on my heart and our relationship).

I love my mom - so I don't say this to demean her - only to encourage other moms not to fall into the same trap. For the sake of your daughter's health and happiness.
1 reply · active 614 weeks ago
Great points and things to consider, Amy. Thank you for sharing.
My mother was always very obsessive about her weight. She still is. And it did really twist the way I thought about my own weight. She has always been small but would freak out over even a pound's difference. I know I have it in me to get that obsessive- so I don't even have a scale in my house. I try to monitor in other ways(fit of clothes, how I feel) and weigh sometimes at the gym, but no daily allowed here.
There definitely is a fine line that needs to be determined. My dad is a nutritionist, so I grew up learning to eat healthily and understanding what unhealthy food was (I was shocked when I got married and found potato chips and soda in our pantry after my husband did the grocery shopping)! I really appreciate how my parents emphasized healthy food choices. However, my mom would comment regularly on my body, especially that my rear was big (which I've come to realize is just how I am made). Looking back, I'm saddened to realize she did that even though I was always skinny. As a young adult, I became very obsessive about my weight and lost too much weight (I only weighed 95 lbs when I got married). But, even at that time, my mom would comment on my big rear! I think it's good to teach healthy eating and exercise habits, but then dwelling too much on weight gain/body image of your children will have a negative impact on your kids. I know it did on me.

Post a new comment

Comments by