Wednesday, October 30, 2013

The Nightmare of Over Commitment


James Dobson finally came out and emphatically stated the detrimental effect women leaving the home to pursue a career has on a family ~

I have never written this before, and I will be criticized for saying so now, but I believe the two-career family during the child-rearing years creates a level of stress that is tearing people apart.  And it often deprives children of something that they will search for the rest of their lives.

For many years, he said that the early years in a child's life are the most important for a mother to be home. Then, he decided that elementary years were just as important. Finally, he changed his mind that high school years were the most important. Now, he has come to the realization that children need a mother in the home during ALL the years that they are under their parent's roof. They need to be taken care of , protected, given boundaries, and trained. 

Dr. Dobson goes on to say ~

My prayer is that a scale-back from a lifestyle of constant time-pressures will someday occur. If it ever becomes a movement, it will portend wonderfully for the family. It should result in fewer divorces and more domestic harmony. Children will regain the status they deserve and their welfare will be enhanced on a thousand fronts. We haven't begun to approach these goals yet, but we can only hope that a significant segment of the population will awaken someday from the nightmare of over commitment and say, "This is a crazy way to live. There has to be a better way than this to raise our kids. We will make the financial sacrifices necessary to slow the pace of living." 

It is not enough simply to be at home and available to our children, however. We must use the opportunities of these few short years to teach them our values and beliefs. Millions of young people who have grown up in the relative opulence of North America have not had that training. They are terribly confused about transcendent values. We have given them more material blessings than any generation in history. They have had opportunities never dreamed of by their ancestors. Most have never heard the pounding of artillery shells or the explosion of grenades. More money has been spent on their education, medical care, entertainment, and travel than any who have gone before. Yew we have failed them in the most important of all parental responsibilities: We have not taught them who they are as children of God or what they have been placed here to do.

Most pastors and teachers are afraid to say these kind of things these days because so many women will get offended. Many women would probably leave a church that taught this! We should never be afraid of teaching God's truths. We must continue to shine the light of Truth in this dark world. Children need a mother at home. They do. They really do.


She looks well to the ways of her household 
and does not eat the bread of idleness.
Proverbs 31:27

Comments (26)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
I came from a two working parent home. My parents are still together and us children are loving, well-adjusted children. But looking back, I LOVE/D my mother. She is one of the smartest, most talented women I know. Would I have preferred to have spent more time at her feet learning from her? You bet! Not only was she super talented, but she loved me like none of my teachers or babysitters ever could. I know I would have been better off if she could have been home full-time. I am just glad that God redeems!
2 replies · active 595 weeks ago
I am a stay at home mom, my childrens ages are 22, 13, and 9. One of the most important things I learned was this: the older my kids get, the more they need me. So many people have asked me when I am going back to work. I can tell you, my 22 year old daughter taught me that the older she got, the more guidance she needed. So many women go back to work when the kids go to school. Moms, please hear this, they need you more then ever as they grow up. Yes, my daughter went to a specialized Science, Math public school. It was an amazing experience. I was home, guiding, protecting, each step of the way. I feel so strongly about women staying home through their children's ENTIRE childhood. The world will take them away. Yes, we made and continue to make HUGE sacrifices for me to stay home, but it is soooo worth it.
2 replies · active 595 weeks ago
No doubt it is a tremendous blessing to have a stay at home Mom and wife in a family. Unfortunately, our society counts success, security and social status based on the bigger home, nicer cars, bigger 401K and the best of vacations, instead of seeing the value of a Proverbs 31 Mom and wife.

Our four kids would not be who they are today without Lori being there for them. The value of a stay at home Mom is golden... but certainly all things done to God's ideal are that way. A Mom working is at times a necessity, but Christians must rightfully judge between what is truly a necessity or simply having nicer things, while losing the hearts of your kids to the world.
I fully agree with you. I got to stay home before they started school and then my husband took a job that did not even pay our mortgage. I had to work and work long hours. To this day it still makes me sad to think of everything I missed in my children's lives because of that decision. I have now been disabled for eight years and got to spend the last of my youngest's high school years with her. I hope to be able to spend the time with my future grandchildren that I didn't get to spend with my children.
Thank you Lori for speaking from your heart. So many people side step the truth. We need women of discernment who will tell it like it is to the younger women. I was one of those children who had a working mom. I hated it. I would have rather sat on lawn chairs and wore
rags to have her stay home with me. I still struggle with searching for why she didn't feel complete in the home when she made the choice to have kids. My dad made a good living but she had to have the latest everything. I am so grateful that I had women in my church who could disciple me to learn what you are teaching others. Keep up the great work. If those don't like what you are saying, they can stop reading your posts but most of us are cheering you on.
Diane
I was raised Mormon and have never been around Christians much. In the Mormon church all women are advised that if possible not to work and stay at home with their children--from the very top authority of the church down. But women are not condemned if they do have to work (from the church authorities anyway, there are members that might look down on others) and I haven't known anyone to be offended and leave church over statements like these. My point is that it is certainly taught and encouraged to the girls basically from birth.

So, based upon that background, I'm curious why you would think that women in the Christian churches would be offended and leave? Does that happen? And is this not being taught in the Christian churches?

Any insight will be appreciated! I enjoy reading your blog even though I am not a Christian. I have learned a lot about the religion and why certain things are done or believed :)
2 replies · active 595 weeks ago
I don't see anything in Dobson's comment quoted above that it is the mother who should stay home.
Cynthia Swenson's avatar

Cynthia Swenson · 595 weeks ago

I love Dr. Dobson & this is such a good post, Lori. Someone pointed out that God redeems everything in our lives. I just want to testify that He really does work EVERYTHING out for our good & while I'm the first to admit I don't understand everything, He DOES help me understand SOME things. I am thankful at this point, that I learned to be quite independent & responsible at a young age. I would look around & see things that I thought someone should be doing but were neglected because my mom was tired. So I would just learn to do them myself. Also, I've discovered that absolutely EVERYTHING I might still be "looking for" is to be found in Jesus Christ. He truly is "all we need"! Love & prayers, in Jesus, Cynthia
I'm a child of two working parents. The relationships that I was able to form with my grandparents as a result of their caretaking were irreplaceable. I didn't have "occasion" grandparents; I saw them all weekly and learned so much from them, was disciplined by them, and bonded with them from a young age. But, my parents are my parents, and I recognize the extent of their influence over my life - even if I wasn't with one or the other 24/7.

I don't mean to argue, but I really don't understand what was "missing" from my childhood; what it is that I, as a working parents' kid, am so likely to be searching for.
Amen! I agree whole-heartedly. I shared it on the DRAH page :) Blessings!
I agree! 1,000 percent! :-) Great post! Before we had children I was working and had a great job - when our daughter was born (adoption) -- I stayed at work the 1st year and 1/2 of her life. Then I just couldn't take it anymore.... my husband and I decided together that I would stay home. We had an accountant crunch the numbers and it didn't look good financially as my income was helping greatly. However -- we serve a great God and not only did we have enough - we sometimes have more than enough.... for awhile I babysat after I quit working and that helped somewhat as well.

Also - to comment on the Charlotte's comment above ( the lady who said she was a Mormon) - unfortunately - yes -- the Christian churches are mostly so secularized most Christian women do work and are sadly encouraged to do so - go to college - get a career and put that 1st..... it's a common mindset in the world and sadly in most Christian churches.... it seems to me that most women are looked down upon for wanting to have a family over a career....... so sad - but so true. So yes, most women in Christian churches would be offended to hear such sermons.... so sad to say. Older woman are not instructing younger woman either as it states in the Bible... at least not in my circles. It seems younger women don't revere older woman as they used to.... which is sad too. I ay that to say that it would be nice to see older women modeling to younger women what it's like to have a family and cook and clean and tend the home and ENJOY it and not wish they were working etc. Where are those Christian examples these days? We desperately need them. Even though I am at home - I struggle greatly with anger -- I think some of it due in part to feeling like a I need something more -- grumbling often about cleaning and cooking. I wish I was not as much like this - but I HAVE come a LONG way from where I was in that regard. Still working on meal planning though... that's a tough one.
1 reply · active 595 weeks ago
I was blessed by a stay-at-home mom. In fact, the only day I remember my mother not being home in all my 18 years was the day my daddy's finger got cut off. And I was blessed to be home for my children also. I got up at 4 and wrote until 7 so they could have my attention. Now my daughter has four of her own and it blesses me that her husband gives her the same blessing. As a work-at-home writer I get to teach my granddaughter kindergarten one day a week. Such a joy!
Thank you for this post. I have 5 children and the youngest 2 just went to school all day this year and the oldest hit middle school. Everyone asked me if I was headed back to work now that they were all in school all day. "Um, no...." I usually have to explain. I do agree that as they get older they continue to need me. Actually, I have a lot MORE that I have to keep track of now that they are all school age. It's still busy, just a different kind of busy. I can guarantee that I would be very stressed if we both worked full time. Also, by being available during the day, I am able to volunteer a lot in their school as well as blessing other people in other ways.
1 reply · active 595 weeks ago
@ Sara,
Why would you assume that because in your one particular situation where loving Grandparents stepped in that it would happen for anyone else? You are making a massive leap in cause and effect here and the current culture, societal ills and statistics shown you to be an anomaly who should be eternally grateful rather then someone thinking they are the norm.
I have been a Stay at Home Mom and a Working Mom. I totally agree with Dr. Dobson that it is more stressful for the entire family when mom works. There are also financial stresses that sometimes make it so mom has to work, but overall, if possible and practical, I think it is best if mom stays home as many years as possible. If families were more frugal and stayed out of debt, more moms could stay at home. Thanks.
Lori, I want to thank you for the Biblical teaching you share on your blog. I agree with you 100% on the importance of women making their husbands and children a priority. For many years, I worked part time outside the home and in recent years, more hours than I liked. I constantly felt like I was unable to keep up, exhausted, pulled in every direction, and like I wasn't able to do my job as wife and mother as well as I felt God wanted me to. My heart was to be at home full time. I prayed that God would open the door for me to be home more and for my husband to see how important it was. Last year, I was in a car accident that caused worsening of a brain condition I was unaware I had. I began to have severe headaches and other symptoms from this. I then had to have brain surgery this past January. Because of my condition and the surgery, I was unable to continue working at all due to the physical and stressful nature of my job (Im an RN). It is hard for me to think that God allowed me to go through so much physical suffering to ultimately achieve what I had prayed for. But, He did. Yes we have had to make sacrifices financially, but the change in our family for the better far outweighs any material things. My children love having me at home, and my marriage is stronger than ever before. Even though I still struggle with some residual physical problems, I finally feel that I am able to be the wife and mother that my family deserves. I am exactly where God wants me! My husband has said to me how he sees what value my staying at home has for him and our children.
Thanks again!
anneke vandenberg's avatar

anneke vandenberg · 594 weeks ago

I have been married for 26 years and home schooled 4 children for 15 years. My youngest will be going to school next year. This year I graduated as a social worker and got a 3 day a week job. If I don't work we cannot pay the bills and help 3 children through university.
As parents, we need to be flexible and realistic about costs of living. I am a very frugal person but also very capable. I have taught my children they need to be well educated so they can have a wider range of choices in life and choose a profession where they can use their God given talents.
We need women in Parliament, schools, hospitals, law, etc. Women make up 50% of the population, so I would like to think women also contribute that amount at least! Remember the scriptures that there is a time for everything! Remember the women in the market place who sold and bought garments- this woman was a business woman, so lets stop being idealistic and stop JUDGING other women who do things differently.
Lets learn from each other and work together as husbands and wives ought to- for better and for worse
As if the stress of a one income family is a cake walk. I know that you focus on women, so please take the time to help how to handle stress for all women.

Post a new comment

Comments by