Saturday, September 5, 2015

Where's the Balance in Parenting?


We thought we were strict parents. At least, many people told us that we were. However, when I read this article written by a Chinese mother, I realized we were lenient compared to them. What Chinese parents understand is that nothing is fun until you're good at it. To get good at anything you have to work, and children on their own never want to work, which is why it is crucial to override their preferences.

I absolutely agree with some of the things she wrote. Chinese are known for working extremely hard and not being lazy. When they come over to America, they are usually at the top of their class. They make their children practice their instrument for hours every single day. Nope, no extracurricular activities for them. If they get anything less than an A in school, they are called names and chastised. If their child is overweight, they tell them they are fat and to lose weight. Everything is about their children's performance and Chinese children do perform with excellence!

On the other hand, I believe many American parents are way too lenient on their children. They allow their children to participate in an extracurricular activity and if they don't like it, they can quit even if it hurts the team. If they get a C, they are praised since self-esteem is everything. If they're on a losing team, you still get a trophy. "Maybe we should even get rid of competitive sports since someone always has to lose and it's devastating to their self-esteem." GAG!!! Many parents won't even say NO to their children for fear their children would think they are failures. And NEVER bring up weight; no never! This is completely off limits with your children.

There's got to be a happy medium somewhere in this discussion. I do believe you should have high standards for your children; expecting them to work hard, be honest, love others, and be generous. This woman said nothing about the traits of love: patience, kindness, compassion or tenderness. No, it was ALL about performance. For what? Financial success, accolades, applause? Yes, our children should strive to be all that God wants them to be but there is more to life than getting straight A's, in my opinion.

We must teach our children to be hard-working, productive members of society. We must also teach them to love the Lord, love others, be kind, gentle and patient. All of these virtues will help them live lives that are fulfilling and bring joy to others.

We didn't allow sleepovers for protection's sake; not so they could practice an instrument for three hours a day like the Chinese. We made them do their homework and study hard; not for all A's but to be the best they could be. It was alright with us if they didn't get straight A's. They were still extremely valuable to us. It's a fine balance between pushing too hard and not pushing hard enough. I didn't push hard enough for them to help me around the home and I wish I would have, but they all were great students and were committed to whatever sports they played. We all do our very best and with God's grace, we leave the rest in His hands.

It is for discipline that you endure; 
God deals with you as with sons; 
for what son is there whom his father does not discipline?
Hebrews 12:7

Comments (4)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
Carrion Flowers's avatar

Carrion Flowers · 499 weeks ago

I believe that parents are able to discuss weight with their kids. I just think it should be done tactfully. If someone makes a slight weight gain into a massive negative and makes it sound like their parental love is conditional on a certain body size, I think that's sending an awful, horrible message to a kid with a developing mind and body. People who act like that are saying to their child that in order to be loved, by anyone, much less me (the parents) and to be considered a person in the eyes of others, you must look a certain way. That is despicable. There are better ways to encourage weight loss than calling a child "fat" and expecting a result. Providing healthy and delicious meals and snacks as well as teaching them how to prepare them for the future, teaching them about nutrition and how their body works with what they choose to shove into their gob and encouraging physical activity yourself by playing active games with them or just going for daily walks or bike rides while also having a balance of treats, screen time and couch chillin' is how I do it with my kids. That’s basically how I manage my weight now and how I lost my excess weight too. Diet? Psssht. Diets are aptly named/ They make you die a little on the inside each day that passes.
I read the book Tiger Mom which is excerpted in the article by Amy Chua which you linked to. It was a wonderful read and I highly recommend it. I do agree with you that the important, eternal things often are missed in the Tiger Mom culture. But I do think it is interesting that so many in Eastern cultures are able to be stricter on their children without having the emotional fall out that we have in Western culture where all the children grow up having to get psychiatric care and psychiatric drugs to deal with life.
I have seen some parents practically terrorised by their children. Toddlers and youngsters who rule the roost at home, and their parents allow them to hit, spit, scream and swear at them. And all they'll softly say is "no darling, please don't do that". Unbelievable! I'll never understand this style of permissive parenting. For some unexplained reason it seems to be more popular than ever. How on earth do these parents even enjoy spending any time with such badly behaved children?
Great post, Lori, thank you! Enough with "everyone gets a trophy"! It becomes meaningless. We want our kids to work hard in school and always do their best, but if they fail once in a while, they will learn how to get back up, and develop some compassion in the process. I think that is one of the best lessons they can learn. We have had to discuss weight in our home, and we did it through the providing of healthy food choices (especially snacks) and physical activity, which meant limiting screen time.

Post a new comment

Comments by